Team Of Rivals Part 59

As the carriage neared the White House, Lincoln saw that a group of old friends, including Illinois governor Richard Oglesby, were just leaving. "Come back, boys, come back," he told them, relishing the relaxing company of friends. They remained for some time, Governor Oglesby recalled. "Lincoln got to reading some humorous book; I think it was by 'John Phoenix.' They kept sending for him to come to dinner. He promised each time to go, but would continue reading the book. Finally he got a sort of peremptory order that he must come to dinner at once."

The early dinner was necessary, for the Lincolns had plans to see Laura Keene in Our American Cousin at Ford's Theatre that evening. After supper, the president met with Noah Brooks, Ma.s.sachusetts congressman George Ashmun, and Speaker Colfax, who was soon to depart for California. "How I would rejoice to make that trip!" Lincoln told Colfax, "but public duties chain me down here, and I can only envy you its pleasures." The president invited Colfax to join him at the theater that night, but Colfax had too many commitments.

To Noah Brooks, Lincoln had never seemed "more hopeful and buoyant concerning the condition of the country.... He was full of fun and anecdotes, feeling especially jubilant at the prospect before us." His parting words, Brooks recalled, focused on the country's economic future. "Grant thinks that we can reduce the cost of the army establishment at least a half million a day, which, with the reduction of expenditures of the Navy, will soon bring down our national debt to something like decent proportions, and bring our national paper up to a par, or nearly so with gold."

Speaker Colfax was among several people who declined the Lincolns' invitation to the theater that evening. The morning edition of the National Republican had announced that the Grants would join the Lincolns in the president's box that night, but Julia Grant had her heart set on visiting their children in New Jersey, so Grant asked to be excused. The Stantons also declined. Stanton, like Chase, considered the theater a foolish diversion and, more important, a dangerous one. He had fought a losing battle for months to keep the president from such public places, and he felt that his presence would only sanction an unnecessary hazard. Earlier that day, "unwilling to encourage the theater project," Stanton had refused to let his chief telegrapher, Thomas Eckert, accept Lincoln's invitation, even though the president had teasingly requested him for his uncommon strength-he had been known to "break a poker over his arm" and could serve as a bodyguard.

It was after eight when the Lincolns entered their carriage to drive to the theater. "I suppose it's time to go," Lincoln told Colfax, "though I would rather stay." While nothing had provided greater diversion during the bitter nights of his presidency than the theater, Lincoln required no escape on this happy night. Still, he had made a commitment. "It has been advertised that we will be there," he told his bodyguard, Crook, who had the night off, "and I cannot disappoint the people." Clara Harris-the daughter of Mary's friend Senator Ira Harris-and her fiance, Major Henry Rathbone, joined the Lincolns in their carriage.

AS THE LINCOLNS RODE to Ford's Theatre on 10th Street, John Wilkes Booth and three conspirators were a block away at the Herndon House. Booth had devised a plan that called for the simultaneous a.s.sa.s.sinations of President Lincoln, Secretary of State Seward, and Vice President Johnson. Having learned that morning of Lincoln's plan to attend the theater, he had decided that this night would provide their best opportunity. The powerfully built Lewis Powell, accompanied by David Herold, was a.s.signed to kill Seward at his Lafayette Square home. Meanwhile, the carriage maker George Atzerodt was to shoot the vice president in his suite at the Kirkwood Hotel. Booth, whose familiarity with the stagehands would ensure access, would a.s.sa.s.sinate the president.

Just as Brutus had been honored for slaying the tyrant Julius Caesar, Booth believed he would be exalted for killing an even "greater tyrant." a.s.sa.s.sinating Lincoln would not be enough. "Booth knew," his biographer observes, "that in the end, the Brutus conspiracy was foiled by Marc Antony, whose famous oration made outlaws of the a.s.sa.s.sins and a martyr of Caesar." William Henry Seward, Lincoln's Mark Antony, must not live. Finally, to throw the entire North into disarray, the vice president must die as well. The triple a.s.sa.s.sinations were set for 10:15 p.m.

STILL BEDRIDDEN, Seward had enjoyed his best day since his nearly fatal carriage accident nine days earlier. f.a.n.n.y Seward noted in her diary that he had slept well the previous night and had taken "solid food for the first time." In the afternoon, he had "listened with a look of pleasure to the narrative of the events of the Cabinet meeting," which Fred, as a.s.sistant secretary, had attended in his father's stead. Later in the afternoon, he had listened to f.a.n.n.y's reading of "Enoch Arden" and remarked on how much he enjoyed it.

The three-story house was full of people. The entire family, except Will and Jenny, were there-Frances, Augustus, Fred, Anna, and f.a.n.n.y. In addition to the half-dozen household servants and the State Department messenger rooming on the third floor, two soldiers had been a.s.signed by Stanton to stay with Seward. In the early evening, Edwin Stanton had stopped by to check on his friend and colleague. He stayed for a while, chatting with other visitors until martial music in the air reminded him that War Department employees had planned on serenading him that night at his home six blocks away.

After all the guests left, "the quiet arrangements for the night" began. To ensure that Seward was never left alone, the family members had taken turns sitting by his bed. That night f.a.n.n.y was scheduled to stay with him until 11 p.m., when her brother Gus would relieve her. George Robinson, one of the soldiers whom Stanton had detailed to the household, was standing by. Shortly after 10 p.m., f.a.n.n.y noticed that her father was falling asleep. She closed the pages of the Legends of Charlemagne, turned down the gas lamps, and took a seat on the opposite side of the bed.

Fred Seward later wrote that "there seemed nothing unusual in the occurrence, when a tall, well dressed, but unknown man presented himself" at the door. Powell told the servant who answered the bell that he had some medicine for Mr. Seward and had been instructed by his physician to deliver it in person. "I told him he could not go up," the servant later testified, "that if he would give me the medicine, I would tell Mr. Seward how to take it." Powell was so insistent that the boy stepped aside. When he reached the landing, Fred Seward stopped him. "My father is asleep; give me the medicine and the directions; I will take them to him." Powell argued that he must deliver it in person, but Fred refused.

At this point, Fred recalled, the intruder "stood apparently irresolute." He began to head down the stairs, then "suddenly turning again, he sprang up and forward, having drawn a Navy revolver, which he levelled, with a muttered oath, at my head, and pulled the trigger." This was the last memory Fred would have of that night. The pistol misfired, but Powell brought it down so savagely that Fred's skull was crushed in two places, exposing his brain and rendering him unconscious.

Hearing the disturbance, Private Robinson ran to the door from Seward's bedside. The moment the door was opened, Powell rushed inside, brandishing his now broken pistol in one hand and a large knife in the other. He slashed Robinson in the forehead with his knife, knocking him "partially down," and headed toward Seward. f.a.n.n.y ran beside Powell, begging him not to kill her father. When Seward heard the word "kill," he awakened, affording him "one glimpse of the a.s.sa.s.sin's face bending over" before the large bowie knife plunged into his neck and face, severing his cheek so badly that "the flap hung loose on his neck." Oddly, he would later recall that his only impressions were what a fine-looking man Powell was and "what handsome cloth that overcoat is made of."

f.a.n.n.y's screams brought her brother Gus into the room as Powell advanced again upon Seward, who had been knocked to the floor by the force of the blows. Gus and the injured Robinson managed to pull Powell away, but not before he struck Robinson again and slashed Gus on the forehead and the right hand. When Gus ran for his pistol, Powell bolted down the stairs, stabbing Emerick Hansell, the young State Department messenger, in the back before he bolted out the door and fled through the city streets.

The clamor had roused the entire household. Anna sent the servant to fetch Dr. Verdi, while Private Robinson, though bleeding from his head and shoulders, lifted Seward onto the bed and instructed f.a.n.n.y about "staunching the blood with clothes & water." Still fearing that another a.s.sa.s.sin might be hiding in the house, Frances and Anna checked the attic while f.a.n.n.y searched the rooms on the parlor floor.

Dr. Verdi would never forget his first sight of Seward that night. "He looked like an exsanguinated corpse. In approaching him my feet went deep in blood. Blood was streaming from an extensive gash in his swollen cheek; the cheek was now laid open." So "frightful" was the wound and "so great was the loss of blood" that Verdi a.s.sumed the jugular vein must have been cut. Miraculously, it was not. Further examination revealed that the knife had been deflected by the metal contraption holding Seward's broken jaw in place. In bizarre fashion, the carriage accident had saved his life.

"I had hardly sponged his face from the b.l.o.o.d.y stains and replaced the flap," Verdi recalled, "when Mrs. Seward, with an intense look, called me to her. 'Come and see Frederick,' said she." Not understanding, he followed Frances to the next room, where he "found Frederick bleeding profusely from the head." Fred's appearance was so "ghastly" and his wounds so large that Verdi feared he would not live, but with the application of "cold water pledgets," he was able to stanch the bleeding temporarily.

Once Fred was stabilized, Frances drew Dr. Verdi into another room on the same floor. "For Heaven's sake, Mrs. Seward," asked the befuddled doctor, "what does all this mean?" Verdi found Gus lying on the bed with stab wounds on his hand and forehead, but a.s.sured Frances that he would recover. Frances barely had time to absorb these words of comfort before entreating Dr. Verdi to see Private Robinson. "I ceased wondering," Verdi recalled, "my mind became as if paralyzed; mechanically I followed her and examined Mr. Robinson. He had four or five cuts on his shoulders."

"Any more?" Verdi asked, though not imagining the carnage could go on. "Yes," Frances answered, "one more." She led him to Mr. Hansell, "piteously groaning on the bed." Stripping off the young man's clothes, Verdi "found a deep gash just above the small of the back, near the spine."

"And all this," Verdi thought, "the work of one man-yes, of one man!"

IN PREPARING FOR the attack on the vice president, George Atzerodt had taken a room at the Kirkwood Hotel, where Johnson was staying. At 10:15, he was supposed to ring the bell of Suite 68, enter the room by force, find his target, and murder him. When first informed that the original plan to kidnap the president had shifted to a triple a.s.sa.s.sination, he had balked. "I won't do it," he had insisted. "I enlisted to abduct the President of the United States, not to kill." He had eventually agreed to help, but fifteen minutes before the appointed moment, seated at the bar of the Kirkwood House, he changed his mind, left the hotel, and never returned.

JOHN WILKES BOOTH had left little to chance in his plot to kill the president. Though already well acquainted with the layout of Ford's Theatre, Booth had attended a dress rehearsal the day before to better rehea.r.s.e his scheme for shooting Lincoln in the state box and then escaping into the alley beside the theater. That morning he had again visited the theater to collect his mail, chatting amiably in the front lobby with the theater owner's brother, Harry Ford. Booth had already taken his place inside the theater when the Lincolns arrived.

The play had started as the presidential party entered the flag-draped box in the dress circle. The notes of "Hail to the Chief" brought the audience to their feet, applauding wildly and craning to see the president. Lincoln responded "with a smile and bow" before taking his seat in a comfortable armchair at the center of the box, with Mary by his side. Clara Harris was seated at the opposite end of the box, while Henry Rathbone occupied a small sofa on her left. Observing the president and first lady, one theatergoer noticed that she "rested her hand on his knee much of the time, and often called his attention to some humorous situation on the stage." Mary herself later recalled that as she snuggled ever closer to her husband, she had whispered, "What will Miss Harris think of my hanging on to you so?" He had looked at her and smiled. "She wont think any thing about it."

During the performance, the White House footman delivered a message to the president. At about twelve minutes after ten, the impeccably dressed John Wilkes Booth presented his calling card to the footman and gained admittance to the box. Once inside, he raised his pistol, pointed it at the back of the president's head, and fired.

As Lincoln slumped forward, Henry Rathbone attempted to grab the intruder. Booth pulled out his knife, slashed Rathbone in the chest, and managed to leap from the box onto the stage fifteen feet below. "As he jumped," one eyewitness recalled, "one of the spurs on his riding-boots caught in the folds of the flag draped over the front, and caused him to fall partly on his hands and knees as he struck the stage." Another onlooker observed that "he was suffering great pain," but, "making a desperate effort, he struggled up." Raising "his shining dagger in the air, which reflected the light as though it had been a diamond," he shouted the now historic words of the Virginia state motto-"Sic semper tyrannis" (Thus always to tyrants)-and ran from the stage.

Until the screams broke forth from the president's box, many in the audience thought the dramatic moment was part of the play. Then they saw Mary Lincoln frantically waving. "They have shot the President!" she cried. "They have shot the President!" Charles Leale, a young doctor seated near the presidential box, was the first to respond. "When I reached the President," he recalled, "he was almost dead, his eyes were closed." Unable at first to locate the wound, he stripped away Lincoln's coat and collar. Examining the base of the skull, he discovered "the perfectly smooth opening made by the ball." Using his finger "as a probe" to remove "the coagula which was firmly matted with the hair," he released the flow of blood, relieving somewhat the pressure on Lincoln's brain. Another doctor, Charles Sabin Taft, Julia Taft's half brother, soon arrived, and the decision was made to remove the president from the crowded box to a room in the Petersen boardinghouse across the street.

By this time, people had ma.s.sed in the street. The word began to spread that a.s.sa.s.sins had attacked not only Lincoln but Seward as well. Joseph Sterling, a young clerk in the War Department, rushed to inform Stanton of the calamity. On his way, he encountered his roommate, J. G. Johnson, who joined him on the terrible errand. "When Johnson and I reached Stanton's residence," Sterling recalled, "I was breathless," so when Stanton's son Edwin Jr. opened the door, Johnson was the one to speak. "We have come," Johnson said, "to tell your father that President Lincoln has been shot." Young Stanton hurried to his father, who had been undressing for bed. When the war secretary came to the door, Sterling recalled, "he fairly shouted at me in his heavy tones: 'Mr. Sterling what news is this you bring?'" Sterling told him that both Lincoln and Seward had been a.s.sa.s.sinated. Desperately hoping this news was mere rumor, Stanton remained calm and skeptical. "Oh, that can't be so," he said, "that can't be so!" But when another clerk arrived at the door to describe the attack on Seward, Stanton had his carriage brought around at once, and against the appeals of his wife, who feared that he, too, might be a target, he headed for Seward's house at Lafayette Square.

The news reached Gideon Welles almost simultaneously. He had already gone to bed when his wife reported someone at the door. "I arose at once," Welles recorded in his diary, "and raised a window, when my messenger, James called to me that Mr. Lincoln the President had been shot," and that Seward and his son had been a.s.sa.s.sinated. Welles thought the story "very incoherent and improbable," but the messenger a.s.sured him that he had already been to Seward's house to check its veracity before coming to see his boss. Also ignoring his wife's protests, Welles dressed and set forth in the foggy night for the Seward house on the other side of the square.

Upon reaching Seward's house, Welles and Stanton were shocked at what they found. Blood was everywhere-on "the white wood work of the entry," on the stairs, on the dresses of the women, on the floor of the bedroom. Seward's bed, Welles recalled, "was saturated with blood. The Secretary was lying on his back, the upper part of his head covered by a cloth, which extended down over his eyes." Welles questioned Dr. Verdi in a whisper, but Stanton was unable to mute his stentorian voice until the doctor asked for quiet. After looking in on Fred's unconscious form, the two men walked together down the stairs. In the lower hall, they exchanged what information they had regarding the president. Welles thought they should go to the White House, but Stanton believed Lincoln was still at the theater. Army quartermaster general Meigs, who had just come to the door, implored them not to go to 10th Street, where thousands of people had gathered. When they insisted, he decided to join them.

Twelve blocks away, in his home at Sixth and E streets, Chief Justice Chase had already retired for the night. Earlier that afternoon, he had taken a carriage ride with Nettie, intending to stop at the White House to remonstrate with Lincoln over his too lenient approach to Reconstruction and his failure to demand universal suffrage. At the last minute, "uncertain how [Lincoln] would take it," Chase had decided to wait until the following day.

He was fast asleep when a servant knocked on his bedroom door. There was a gentleman downstairs, the servant said, who claimed "the President had been shot." The caller was a Treasury employee who had actually witnessed the shooting "by a man who leaped from the box upon the stage & escaped by the rear." Chase hoped "he might be mistaken," but in short order, three more callers arrived. Each "confirmed what I had been told & added that Secretary Seward had also been a.s.sa.s.sinated, and that guards were being placed around the houses of all the prominent officials, under the apprehension that the plot had a wide range. My first impulse was to rise immediately & go to the President...but reflecting that I could not possibly be of any service and should probably be in the way of those who could, I resolved to wait for morning & further intelligence. In a little while the guard came-for it was supposed that I was one of the destined victims-and their heavy tramp-tramp was heard under my window all night.... It was a night of horrors."

When Stanton and Welles arrived at the crammed room in the Petersen boardinghouse, they found that Lincoln had been placed diagonally across a bed to accommodate his long frame. Stripped of his shirt, "his large arms," Welles noted, "were of a size which one would scarce have expected from his spare appearance." His devastating wound, the doctors reported with awe, "would have killed most men instantly, or in a very few minutes. But Mr. Lincoln had so much vitality" that he continued to struggle against the inevitable end.

Mary spent most of the endless night weeping in an adjoining parlor, where several women friends tried vainly to comfort her. "About once an hour," Welles noted, she "would repair to the bedside of her dying husband and with lamentation and tears remain until overcome by emotion." She could only rotely repeat the question "Why didn't he shoot me? Why didn't he shoot me?" Though everyone in the room knew the president was dying, Mary was not told, out of fear that she would collapse. Whenever she came into the room, Dr. Taft recalled, "clean napkins were laid over the crimson stains on the pillow."

Early on, Mary sent a messenger for Robert, who had remained at home that night in the company of John Hay. He had already turned in when the White House doorkeeper came to his room. "Something happened to the President," Thomas Pendel told Robert, "you had better go down to the theater and see what it is." Robert asked Pendel to get Hay. Reaching Hay's room, Pendel told him, "Captain Lincoln wants to see you at once. The President has been shot." Pendel recalled that when Hay heard the news, "he turned deathly pale, the color entirely leaving his cheeks." The two young men jumped in a carriage, picking up Senator Sumner along the way.

Mary was torn over whether to summon Tad, but was apparently persuaded that the emotional boy would be devastated if he saw his father's condition. Tad and his tutor had gone that night to Grover's Theatre to see Aladdin. The theater had been decorated with patriotic emblems, and a poem commemorating Fort Sumter's recapture was read aloud between the acts. An eyewitness recalled that the audience was "enjoying the spectacle of Aladdin" when the theater manager came forward, "as pale as a ghost." A look of "mortal agony" contorted his face as he announced to the stunned audience that the president had been shot at Ford's Theatre. In the midst of the pandemonium that followed, Tad was seen running "like a young deer, shrieking in agony."

"Poor little Tad," Pendel recalled, returned to the White House in tears. "O Tom Pen! Tom Pen!" Tad wailed. "They have killed Papa dead. They've killed Papa dead!" Pendel carried the little boy into Lincoln's bedroom. Turning down the bedcovers, he helped Tad undress and finally got him to lie down. "I covered him up and laid down beside him, put my arm around him, and talked to him until he fell into a sound sleep."

By midnight the entire cabinet, with the exception of Seward, had gathered in the small room at the Petersen boardinghouse. An eyewitness noted that Robert Lincoln "bore himself with great firmness, and constantly endeavored to a.s.suage the grief of his mother by telling her to put her trust in G.o.d." Despite his brave attempts to console others, he was sometimes "entirely overcome" and "would retire into the hall and give vent to most heartrending lamentations." Almost no one was able to contain his grief that night, for as one witness observed, "there was not a soul present that did not love the president."

To Edwin Stanton fell the onerous task of alerting the generals, taking the testimony of witnesses at the theater, and orchestrating the search for the a.s.sa.s.sins. "While evidently swayed by the great shock which held us all under its paralyzing influence," Colonel A. F. Rockwell noted, "he was not only master of himself but unmistakably the dominating power over all. Indeed, the members of the cabinet, much as children might to their father, instinctively deferred to him in all things."

Throughout the night, Stanton dictated numerous dispatches, which were carried to the War Department telegraph office by a relay team of messengers positioned nearby. "Each messenger," Stanton's secretary recalled, "after handing a dispatch to the next, would run back to his post to wait for the next." The first telegram went to General Grant, requesting his immediate presence in Washington. "The President was a.s.sa.s.sinated at Ford's Theater at 10.30 to-night and cannot live.... Secretary Seward and his son Frederick were also a.s.sa.s.sinated at their residence and are in a dangerous condition." The dispatch reached Grant in the Bloodgood Hotel, where he was taking supper. He "dropped his head," Horace Porter recalled, "and sat in perfect silence." Noticing that he had turned "very pale," Julia Grant guessed that bad news had arrived and asked him to read the telegram aloud. "First prepare yourself for the most painful and startling news that could be received," he warned. As he made plans to return to Washington, he told Julia that the tidings filled him "with the gloomiest apprehension. The President was inclined to be kind and magnanimous, and his death at this time is an irreparable loss to the South, which now needs so much both his tenderness and magnanimity."

At 1 a.m., Stanton telegraphed the chief of police in New York, telling him to "send here immediately three or four of your best detectives." Half an hour later, he notified General Dix, "The wound is mortal. The President has been insensible ever since it was inflicted, and is now dying." Three hours later, he updated Dix: "The President continues insensible and is sinking." Early eyewitness accounts, Stanton revealed, suggested "that two a.s.sa.s.sins were engaged in the horrible crime, Wilkes Booth being the one that shot the President."

Shortly after dawn, Mary entered the room for the last time. "The death-struggle had begun," Welles recorded. "As she entered the chamber and saw how the beloved features were distorted, she fell fainting to the floor." Restoratives were given, and Mary was a.s.sisted back to the sofa in the parlor, never again to see her husband alive.

No sooner had "the town clocks struck seven," one observer recalled, than "the character of the President's breathing changed. It became faint and low. At intervals it altogether ceased, until we thought him dead. And then it would be again resumed." Lincoln's nine-hour struggle had reached its final moments. "Let us pray," Reverend Phineas D. Gurley said, and everyone present knelt.

At 7:22 a.m., April 15, 1865, Abraham Lincoln was p.r.o.nounced dead. Stanton's concise tribute from his deathbed still echoes. "Now he belongs to the ages."

When Mary was told that he was gone, she piteously demanded, "Oh, why did you not tell me that he was dying." Her moans could be heard throughout the house. Finally, with Robert's help, she was taken to her carriage, which had waited in front of the house through the long night.

Until the moment of Lincoln's death, Stanton's "coolness and self-possession" had seemed "remarkable" to those around him. Now he could not stop the tears that streamed down his cheeks. In the days that followed, even as he worked tirelessly to secure the city and catch the conspirators, "Stanton's grief was uncontrollable," recalled Horace Porter, "and at the mention of Mr. Lincoln's name he would break down and weep bitterly."

While Stanton's raw grief surprised those who had seen only his gruff exterior, John Hay understood. "Not everyone knows, as I do," he wrote Stanton, "how close you stood to our lost leader, how he loved you and trusted you, and how vain were all the efforts to shake that trust and confidence, not lightly given & never withdrawn. All this will be known some time of course, to his honor and yours."

Salmon Chase was up at dawn. Soldiers had guarded him through the "night of horrors," and he was ready to join his colleagues at Lincoln's side. As he reached 10th Street, however, he encountered a.s.sistant Treasury Secretary Maunsell Field. "Is he dead?" Chase asked. "Yes," Field replied, noting that Chase's "eyes were bloodshot, and his entire face was distorted." The Chief Justice had arrived too late, the president was already dead, and his colleagues had dispersed. Uncertain what to do next, Chase walked to Seward's house. Guards had been stationed to prevent entry, but Chase was recognized and allowed into the lower hall. There, doctors told him that Seward "had partially recovered" and, though still in critical condition, "might live-but that Mr. Frederick Seward's case was hopeless."

Chase headed toward the Kirkwood Hotel to call on the man who represented the future: the soon-to-be president, Andrew Johnson. In Johnson's suite, he encountered his old enemies Montgomery Blair and his father. He took Old Man Blair's hand and "with tearful eyes said 'Mr. Blair I hope that from this day there will cease all anger & bitterness between us.'" The old gentleman responded with equal warmth and kindness.

Perhaps more than any of Lincoln's colleagues, the Southern-born Blairs understood that the a.s.sa.s.sination was a calamity for the South. "Those of southern sympathies know now they have lost a friend willing-& more powerful to protect & serve them than they can now ever hope to find again," Elizabeth Blair remarked to her husband in a letter later that day. "Their grief is as honest as that of any one of our side." An editorial in the Richmond Whig expressed similar sentiments, observing that with Lincoln's death, "the heaviest blow which has ever fallen upon the people of the South has descended."

In distant St. Louis, where his son Barton had found him a new house with a large garden and a comfortable study, Edward Bates was shaken by "the astounding news" that reached him by telegram. In his diary, he remarked that beyond the "calamity which the nation has sustained, my private feelings are deeply moved by the sudden murder of my chief, with and under whom I have served the country, through many difficult and trying scenes, and always with mutual sentiments of respect and friendship. I mourn his fall, both for the country and for myself."