On the Old Road Volume Ii Part 5

Supposing that suitable premises could be found, do you not think that many people would contribute modern paintings, and engravings, and various other objects of interest?--I think it is most probable; in fact, I should say certain.

You would view such an attempt with great favor?--Yes; with great delight indeed.

You rather look upon it as the duty of the Government to provide such inst.i.tutions for the people?--I feel that very strongly indeed.

Do you not think that the plan which has been adopted at Versailles, of having modern history ill.u.s.trated by paintings, would prove of great interest to the people?--I should think it would be an admirable plan in every way.

And a very legitimate step to be taken by the Government, for the purpose of encouraging art in that way?--Most truly.

Would it have, do you think, an effect in encouraging art in this country?--I should think so, certainly.

Whose duty would you consider it to be to superintend the formation of such collections? are there any Government officers who are at present capable of organizing a staff for employment in local museums that you are aware of?--I do not know; I have not examined that subject at all.

163. _Chairman._ The Committee would like to understand you more definitely upon the point that has been referred to, as to foreigners and Englishmen. I presume that what you wished the Committee to understand was, that upon the whole, so far as you have observed, more facilities are in point of fact afforded to the working cla.s.ses, in some way or other, abroad than in this country for seeing pictures and visiting public inst.i.tutions?--My answer referred especially to the aspect of the working cla.s.ses as I have watched them in their times of recreation; I see them a.s.sociated with the upper cla.s.ses, more happily for themselves; I see them walking through the Louvre, and walking through the gardens of all the great cities of Europe, and apparently less ashamed of themselves, and more happily combined with all the upper cla.s.ses of society, than they are here. Here our workmen, somehow, are always miserably dressed, and they always keep out of the way, both at such inst.i.tutions and at church. The temper abroad seems to be, while there is a sterner separation and a more aristocratic feeling between the upper and the lower cla.s.ses, yet just on that account the workman confesses himself for a workman, and is treated with affection. I do not say workmen merely, but the lower cla.s.ses generally, are treated with affection, and familiarity, and sympathy by the master or employer, which has to me often been very touching in separate eases; and that impression being on my mind, I answered, not considering that the question was of any importance, hastily; and I am not at present prepared to say how far I could, by thinking, justify that impression.

164. _Mr. Kinnaird._ In your experience, in the last few years, have you not seen a very marked improvement in the working cla.s.ses in this country in every respect to which you have alluded; take the last twenty years, or since you have turned your attention that way?--I have no evidence before me in England of that improvement, because I think that the struggle for existence becomes every day more severe, and that, while greater efforts are made to help the workman, the principles on which our commerce is conducted are every day oppressing him, and sinking him deeper.

Have you ever visited the manufacturing districts of Lancashire and Yorkshire, with a view of ascertaining the state of the people there?--Not with a definite view. My own work has nothing to do with those subjects; and it is only incidentally, because I gratuitously give such instruction as I am able to give at the Working Men's College, that I am able to give you any facts on this subject. All the rest that I can give is, as Sir Robert Peel accurately expressed it, nothing but personal impression.

You admit that the Working Men's College is, after all, a very limited sphere?--A very limited sphere.

165. _Sir Robert Peel._ You have stated that, in the Louvre, a working man looks at the pictures with a greater degree of self-respect than the same cla.s.ses do in the National Gallery here?--I think so.

You surely never saw a man of the upper cla.s.s, in England, scorn at a working man because he appeared in his working dress in the National Gallery in London?--I have certainly seen working men apprehensive of such scorn.

_Chairman._ Is it not the fact, that the upper and lower cla.s.ses scarcely ever meet on the same occasions?--I think, if possible, they do not.

Is it not the fact that the laboring cla.s.ses almost invariably cease labor at such hours as would prevent them from going to see pictures at the time when the upper cla.s.ses do go?--I meant, before, to signify a.s.sent to your question, that they do not meet if it can be avoided.

_Sir Robert Peel._ Take the Crystal Palace as an example; do not working men and all cla.s.ses meet there together, and did you ever see a working man _gene_ in the examination of works of art?--I am sure that a working man very often would not go where he would like to go.

But you think he would abroad?--I think they would go abroad; I only say that I believe such is the fact.

_Mr. Slaney._ Do not you think that the light-hearted temperament of our southern neighbors, and the fineness of the climate, which permits them to enjoy themselves more in the open air, has something to do with it?--I hope that the old name of Merry England may be recovered one of these days. I do not think that it is in the disposition of the inhabitants to be in the least duller than other people.

_Sir Robert Peel._ When was that designation lost?--I am afraid ever since our manufactures have prospered.

_Chairman._ Referring to the Crystal Palace, do you think that that was an appropriate instance to put, considering the working man pays for his own, and is not ashamed to enjoy his own for his own money?--I have never examined the causes of the feeling; it did not appear to me to be a matter of great importance what was the state of feeling in foreign countries. I felt that it depended upon so many circ.u.mstances, that I thought it would be a waste of time to trace it.

166. _Sir Robert Peel._ You stated that abroad the working cla.s.ses were much better dressed?--Yes.

Do you think so?--Yes.

Surely they cannot be better dressed than they are in England, for you hardly know a working man here from an aristocrat?--It is precisely because I do know working men on a Sunday and every other day of the week from an aristocrat that I like their dress better in France; it is the ordinary dress belonging to their position, and it expresses momentarily what they are; it is the blue blouse which hangs freely over their frames, keeping them sufficiently protected from cold and dust; but here it is a shirt open at the collar, very dirty, very much torn, with ragged hair, and a ragged coat, and altogether a dress of misery.

You think that they are better dressed abroad because they wear a blouse?--Because they wear a costume appropriate to their work.

Are you aware that they make it an invariable custom to leave off the blouse on Sundays and on holidays, and that after they have finished their work they take off their blouse?--I am not familiar, nor do I profess to be familiar, with the customs of the Continent; I am only stating my impressions; but I like especially their habit of wearing a national costume. I believe the national costume of work in Switzerland to be at the root of what prosperity Switzerland yet is retaining. I think, for instance, although it may sound rather singular to say so, that the pride which the women take in their clean chemise sleeves, is one of the healthiest things in Switzerland, and that it is operative in every way on the health of the mind and the body, their keeping their costume pure, fresh, and beautiful.

You stated that the working cla.s.ses were better dressed abroad than in England?--As far as I know, that is certainly the fact.

Still their better dress consists of a blouse, which they take off when they have finished their work?--I bow to your better knowledge of the matter.

_Chairman._ Are you aware that a considerable number of the working cla.s.ses are in bed on the Sunday?--Perhaps it is the best place for them.

167. _Mr. Kinnaird._ You trace the deterioration in the condition of the working cla.s.ses to the increase of trade and manufactures in this country?--To the increase of compet.i.tive trades and manufactures.

It is your conviction that we may look upon this vast extension of trade, and commerce, and compet.i.tion, altogether as an evil?--Not on the vast extension of trade, but on the vast extension of the struggle of man with man, instead of the principle of help of man by man.

_Chairman._ I understood you to say, that you did not object to trade, but that you wished each country to produce that which it was best fitted to produce, with a view to an interchange of its commodities with those of other countries?--Yes.

You did not intend to cast a slur upon the idea of compet.i.tion?--Yes, very distinctly; I intended not only to cast a slur, but to express my excessive horror of the principle of compet.i.tion, in every way; for instance, we ought not to try to grow claret here, nor to produce silk; we ought to produce coal and iron, and the French should give us wine and silk.

You say that, with a view to an interchange of such commodities?--Yes.

Each country producing that which it is best fitted to produce?--Yes, as well as it can; not striving to imitate or compete with the productions of other countries. Finally, I believe that the way of ascertaining what ought to be done for the workman in any position, is for any one of us to suppose that he was our own son, and that he was left without any parents, and without any help; that there was no chance of his ever emerging out of the state in which he was, and then, that what we should each of us like to be done for our son, so left, we should strive to do for the workman.

The following a.n.a.lysis of the above evidence was mainly given in the Index to the Report (p. 153).--ED.

139. Is well acquainted with the museums, picture galleries, etc., in the metropolis.--Conducts a drawing cla.s.s at the Working Men's College.

140. Desirableness of the public inst.i.tutions being open in the evening (cp. 154, 161).

141. Remarks relative to the system of teaching expedient for the working cla.s.ses; system pursued by witness at the Working Men's College.--Workmen to aim at rising in their cla.s.s, not _out of_ it (cp. 155).

142. Backward state, intellectually, of the working man of the present time; superiority of the foreigner.

143. Improvement of the National Gallery suggested (cp. 157, 160).

144. Inexpediency of submitting valuable ancient pictures to the risk of injury from gas, etc. (cp. 146, 157).

145. Statement as to the minds of the working cla.s.ses after their day's labor being too much oppressed to enable them to enjoy or appreciate the public inst.i.tutions, if merely opened in the evening.

146. Suggested collection of pictures and prints of a particular character for the inspection of the working cla.s.ses.--Suggestions with a view to special collections of sh.e.l.ls, birds, and plants being prepared for the use of the working cla.s.ses; system of lectures, of ill.u.s.tration, and of intermediate study necessary in connection with such collections (cp. 151-52).

147. Statement as to greater interest being taken in France and other foreign countries than in England in the intellectual development of the working cla.s.ses; examination on this point, and on the effect produced thereby upon the character and demeanor of the working people (cp. 158, 163-64).

148. Objection to circulating valuable or rare works of art throughout the country, on account of the risk of injury--Disapproval of inspectors, etc., going about with the visitors (cp. 159).--Advantage in the upper cla.s.ses lending pictures, etc., for public exhibition.

149. Lectures to working men. Advantage if large printed explanations were placed under every picture (cp. 157, 161).

150. Great desire among the working cla.s.ses to acquire knowledge; grounds of such desire (cp. 155).--Great boon if a museum were formed at the east end of London.

151. Lectures on natural history for working men.

152. Books available on British birds.

153. Intermediate study essential to use of Lectures.--Good attendance at Working Men's College.--Terms and conditions of admission to it.