Old and New Masters Part 20

XXVII

MR. THOMAS HARDY

1. HIS GENIUS AS A POET

Mr. Thomas Hardy, in the opinion of some, is greater as a poet than as a novelist. That is one of the mild heresies in which the amateur of letters loves to indulge. It has about as much truth in it as the statement that Milton was greater as a controversialist than as a poet, or that Lamb's plays are better than his essays. Mr. Hardy has undoubtedly made an original contribution to the poetry of his time. But he has given us no verse that more than hints at the height and depth of the tragic vision which is expressed in _Jude the Obscure_. He is not by temperament a singer. His music is a still small voice unevenly matched against his consciousness of midnight and storm. It is a flutter of wings in the rain over a tomb. His sense of beauty is frail and midge-like compared with his sense of everlasting frustration. The conceptions in his novels are infinitely more poetic than the conceptions in his verse. In _Tess_ and _Jude_ destiny presides with something of the grandeur of the ancient G.o.ds. Except in _The Dynasts_ and a few of the lyrics, there is none of this brooding majesty in his verse. And even in _The Dynasts_, majestic as the scheme of it is, there seems to me to be more creative imagination in the prose pa.s.sages than in the poetry.

Truth to tell, Mr. Hardy is neither sufficiently articulate nor sufficiently fastidious to be a great poet. He does not express life easily in beautiful words or in images. There is scarcely a magical image in the hundred or so poems in the book of his selected verse.

Thus he writes in _I Found Her Out There_ of one who:--

would sigh at the tale Of sunk Lyonesse As a wind-tugged tress Flapped her cheek like a flail.

There could not be an uglier and more prosaic exaggeration than is contained in the image in the last line. And prose intrudes in the choice of words as well as in images. Take, for example, the use of the word "domiciled" in the pa.s.sage in the same poem about--

that western sea, As it swells and sobs, Where she once domiciled.

There are infelicities of the same kind in the first verse of the poem called _At an Inn_:--

When we, as strangers, sought Their catering care, Veiled smiles bespoke their thought Of what we were.

They warmed as they opined Us more than friends-- That we had all resigned For love's dear ends.

"Catering care" is an appalling phrase.

I do not wish to over-emphasize the significance of flaws of this kind.

But, at a time when all the world is eager to do honour to Mr. Hardy's poems, it is surely well to refrain from doing equal honour to his faults. We shall not appreciate the splendid interpretation of earth in _The Return of the Native_ more highly for persuading ourselves that:--

Intermissive aim at the thing sufficeth,

is a line of good poetry. Similarly the critic, if he is to enjoy the best of Mr. Hardy, must also be resolute not to shut his eyes to the worst in such a verse as that with which _A Broken Appointment_ begins:--

You did not come, And marching time drew on, and wore me numb,-- Yet less for loss of your dear presence there Than that I thus found lacking in your make That high compa.s.sion which can overbear Reluctance for pure loving kindness' sake Grieved I, when, as the hope-hour stroked its sum, You did not come.

There are hints of the grand style of lyric poetry in these lines, but phrases like "in your make" and "as the hope-hour stroked its sum" are discords that bring it tumbling to the levels of Victorian commonplace.

What one does bless Mr. Hardy for, however, both in his verse and in his prose, is his bleak sincerity. He writes out of the reality of his experience. He has a temperament sensitive beyond that of all but a few recent writers to the pain and pa.s.sion of human beings. Especially is he sensitive to the pain and pa.s.sion of frustrated lovers. At least half his poems, I fancy, are poems of frustration. And they, hold us under the spell of reality like a tragedy in a neighbour's house, even when they leave us most mournful over the emptiness of the world. One can see how very mournful Mr. Hardy's genius is if one compares it with that of Browning, his master in the art of the dramatic lyric. Browning is also a poet of frustrated lovers. One can remember poem after poem of his with a theme that might easily have served for Mr. Hardy--_Too Late, Cristina, The Lost Mistress, The Last Ride Together, The Statue and the Bust_, to name a few. But what a sense of triumph there is in Browning's tragedies! Even when he writes of the feeble-hearted, as in _The Statue and the Bust_, he leaves us with the feeling that we are in the presence of weakness in a world in which courage prevails. His world is a place of opulence, not of poverty. Compare _The Last Ride Together_ with Mr.

Hardy's _The Phantom Horsewoman_, and you will see a vast energy and beauty issuing from loss in the one, while in the other there is little but a sad shadow. To have loved even for an hour is with Browning to live for ever after in the inheritance of a mighty achievement. To have loved for an hour is, in Mr. Hardy's imagination, to have deepened the sadness even more than the beauty of one's memories.

Not that Mr. Hardy's is quite so miserable a genius as is commonly supposed. It is false to picture him as always on his knees before the grave-worm. His faith in beauty and joy may be only a thin flame, but it is never extinguished. His beautiful lyric, _I Look into my Gla.s.s_, is the cry of a soul dark but not utterly darkened:--

I look into my gla.s.s, And view my wasting skin, And say: "Would G.o.d, it came to pa.s.s My heart had shrunk as thin!"

For then, I, undistrest, By hearts grown cold to me, Could lonely wait my endless rest With equanimity.

But Time, to make me grieve, Part steals, lets part abide; And shakes this fragile frame at eve With throbbings of noontide.

That is certainly worlds apart from the unquenchable joy of Browning's "All the breath and the bloom of the world in the bag of one bee"; but it is also far removed from the "Lo! you may always end it where you will" of _The City of Dreadful Night_. And despair is by no means triumphant in what is perhaps the most attractive of all Mr. Hardy's poems, _The Oxen_:--

Christmas Eve, and twelve of the clock, "Now they are all on their knees,"

An elder said as we sat in a flock By the embers in hearthside ease.

We pictured the meek mild creatures where They dwelt in their strawy pen, Nor did it occur to one of us there To doubt they were kneeling then.

So fair a fancy few would weave In these years! Yet, I feel, If some one said on Christmas Eve, "Come; see the oxen kneel

"In the lonely barton by yonder coomb Our childhood used to know,"

I should go with him in the gloom, Hoping it might be so.

The mood of faith, however--or, rather, of delight in the memory of faith--is not Mr. Hardy's prevailing mood. At the same time, his unfaith relates to the duration of love rather than to human destiny. He believes in "the world's amendment." He can enter upon a war without ironical doubts, as we see in the song _Men who March Away_. More than this, he can look forward beyond war to the coming of a new patriotism of the world. "How long," he cries, in a poem written some years ago:--

How long, O ruling Teutons, Slavs, and Gaels, Must your wroth reasonings trade on lives like these, That are as puppets in a playing hand?

When shall the saner softer polities Whereof we dream, have sway in each proud land, And Patriotism, grown G.o.dlike, scorn to stand Bondslave to realms, but circle earth and seas?

But, perhaps, his characteristic att.i.tude to war is to be found, not in lines like these, but in that melancholy poem, _The Souls of the Slain_, in which the souls of the dead soldiers return to their country and question a "senior soul-flame" as to how their friends and relatives have kept their doughty deeds in remembrance:--

"And, General, how hold out our sweethearts, Sworn loyal as doves?"

"Many mourn; many think It is not unattractive to prink Them in sable for heroes. Some fickle and fleet hearts Have found them new loves."

"And our wives?" quoth another, resignedly, "Dwell they on our deeds?"

"Deeds of home; that live yet Fresh as new--deeds of fondness or fret, Ancient words that were kindly expressed or unkindly, These, these have their heeds."

Mr. Hardy has too bitter a sense of reality to believe much in the glory of war. His imagination has always been curiously interested in soldiers, but that is more because they have added a touch of colour to the tragic game of life than because he is on the side of the military show. One has only to read _The Dynasts_ along with _Barrack-room Ballads_ to see that the att.i.tude of Mr. Hardy to war is the att.i.tude of the brooding artist in contrast with that of the music-hall politician.

Not that Mr. Kipling did not tell us some truths about the fate of our fellows, but he related them to an atmosphere that savoured of beer and tobacco rather than of eternity. The real world to Mr. Hardy is the world of ancient human things, in which war has come to be a hideous irrelevance. That is what he makes emphatically clear in _In the Time of the Breaking of Nations_:--

Only a man harrowing clods In a slow silent walk With an old horse that stumbles and nods Half asleep as they stalk.

Only thin smoke without flame From the heaps of couch gra.s.s: Yet this will go onward the same Though Dynasties pa.s.s.

Yonder a maid and her wight Come whispering by; War's annals will fade into night Ere their story die

It may be thought, on the other hand, that Mr. Hardy's poems about war are no more expressive of tragic futility than his poems about love.

Futility and frustration are ever-recurring themes in both. His lovers, like his soldiers, rot in the grave defeated of their glory. Lovers are always severed both in life and in death:--

Rain on the windows, creaking doors, With blasts that besom the green, And I am here, and you are there, And a hundred miles between!

In _Beyond the Last Lamp_ we have the same mournful cry over severance.

There are few sadder poems than this with its tristful refrain, even in the works of Mr. Hardy. It is too long to quote in full, but one may give the last verses of this lyric of lovers in a lane:--

When I re-trod that watery way Some hours beyond the droop of day, Still I found pacing there the twain Just as slowly, just as sadly, Heedless of the night and rain.

One could but wonder who they were And what wild woe detained them there.

Though thirty years of blur and blot Have slid since I beheld that spot, And saw in curious converse there Moving slowly, moving sadly, That mysterious tragic pair, Its olden look may linger on-- All but the couple; they have gone.

Whither? Who knows, indeed.... And yet To me, when nights are weird and wet, Without those comrades there at tryst Creeping slowly, creeping sadly, That love-lane does not exist.

There they seem brooding on their pain, And will, while such a lane remain.