Matters Of The Heart Part 11

"Yeah, let's hold off on baby-making right now, if that's okay with you." The more she talked to him, the more she liked him. He sounded like a decent, down-to-earth person. She was using him as a sounding board, she realized, to try and make sense of it herself.

"Fine with me. And another thing was that I found a photograph of a woman he went out with when he was young, a long time ago. He said she killed herself and was pregnant by him. She committed suicide, and he asked me if I would ever do that. I got the creepy feeling that he felt somehow that that was a tribute to him and how much she loved him." He didn't tell Hope that, but listening to her, for the first time, Robert Bartlett was scared. This was beginning to sound dangerous to him, and familiar. Strung all together it was the cla.s.sic portrait of a sociopath. And she was his ideal victim, she was isolated with him in Ireland, had no family or friends nearby, she was in love with him, she had money, a lot of it, and was entirely at his mercy, and would be much more so if they got married. Robert was very glad Hope had called him. He asked her then if she had children. There was another brief silence at her end. "I had a daughter who died four years ago, of meningitis. She was at Dartmouth."

"I'm so sorry." He sounded like he really meant it, which touched her. "I can't imagine anything worse. My worst nightmare is something like that happening. I have two kids in college. Just their going out at night and driving drives me crazy."

"I know," she said softly.

Robert Bartlett also realized now that she didn't have kids to observe what was happening, be alert, or warn her. Hope was every sociopath's dream, a woman without family or protection, and a h.e.l.l of a lot of money. And worse yet, he could sense that she loved him, maybe even now. There was a quality of disbelief to what she was telling him, as though she wanted to piece the puzzle together for him, and have him tell her there was nothing to worry about, and it was not what it appeared to be. So far he couldn't do that for her. It sounded pretty bad, and frightening. And there was a seeming innocence to her that alarmed him even more. Just knowing this much, he thought she was in real danger. Finn O'Neill sounded like a con artist of the first order. The suicide of the previous girlfriend concerned him, as did O'Neill's determination to get Hope pregnant. At least it meant he didn't want her dead. Right now, she was more useful to him alive, married, and pregnant. Unless she gave him trouble, or interfered with his plans, which was what she was currently doing. She had postponed the marriage, refused him money, and didn't want to get pregnant again at the moment. All bad news for him. It meant he would have to work harder to convince her, and if he couldn't, she was going to be in serious danger. And the worst thing about sociopaths, Bartlett knew, was that they induced their victims to destroy themselves so they didn't have to do the dirty work, like Finn's old girlfriend. But so far, Hope still sounded sane. He was doubly glad she had called him, and that her agent had given her his number. He had dealt with situations like this before, although Finn seemed like a particularly able pro at the game. He was good.

"So those were the lies I discovered on my own," Hope went on. "But the last one made me nervous, the lawsuit and his publishing contract. He told me that time too that he was ashamed to tell me the truth, in contrast to my own success. He always uses that same excuse about being embarra.s.sed so he didn't tell me. The truth is, I think he just lies. Everything was fine between us until last June when I lost the baby. He blamed me for it, and said I wasn't careful enough so I caused the miscarriage. He was pretty nasty, very disappointed, and very angry. And he wanted me to get pregnant again right away. My doctor wanted me to wait, because I almost died." Bartlett winced as he listened. It sounded grim yet again.

"But before all that, he was wonderful to me, and thrilled about the baby. We didn't have fertility treatment by the way, it happened on its own. We knew that I was ovulating, he got me drunk, and we had s.e.x without protection. He knew what he was doing." Bartlett was convinced of that by now, she was preaching to the choir. "And it worked. Anyway, for six months everything was wonderful, and after the miscarriage, it was fine again for the summer. But now, he's angry at me all the time, or most of the time. Sometimes he's absolutely wonderful to me again, and then he gets vicious. He's drinking more than he used to. I think he's pretty stressed about the lawsuit, and he's not writing. And he's really angry that I've been postponing the wedding. All of a sudden, we're fighting all the time, and he's always pushing me about something. He never did that before. It was perfect, he was wonderful to me, and he still is sometimes, but it's bad more than it's good now. And sometimes it changes so often and so suddenly, he goes from bad to good to bad to good again, my head is spinning. By the time I left Dublin a week ago, I was so confused, I didn't know what to think. And he kept telling me I was going crazy. I started to believe him."

"That's what he wants you to believe. I can tell from talking to you, Hope, you're not crazy. But I'm equally sure he is. I'm no psychiatrist, but this guy is a textbook case in sociopathy. This is very scary stuff, particularly trying to brainwash and confuse you. When did he ask you for the money?"

"A few weeks ago. He just came right out and asked for it. I said no, and we've been fighting ever since. It concerned me, so when I came to New York in November to do some work, I had my agent hire someone to do an investigation." She sighed then, and told him what the report contained. "His brother thinks he's a sociopath. Even his saying he was an only child wasn't true, he had three brothers. His mother was a maid, not an aristocrat, his father died in a bar fight and wasn't a doctor. Absolutely nothing he told me about his history is true, which is how I know the house in Ireland isn't his ancestral home. And everybody else who's ever known him says he's a pathological liar." That much they both knew was true from what she had told him so far. "The rest of the report came yesterday, and it's no better. His wife died in an accident. He was driving drunk. He had told me she was alone in the car and died. The report says that he was with her, she was alive at the time of the accident. He had a concussion and didn't call for help and she died. Although to be fair, the medical report said she would have died anyway." Even now, she was trying to be kind to Finn. Robert Bartlett considered it a bad sign. She was still in love with him, and hadn't fully a.s.similated the new information she'd gotten. It was too shocking, and hard for her to accept. "He got a suspended prison sentence for manslaughter and five years' probation for killing the other driver," she went on. "And there are some other minor upsetting stories. His wife's parents think he was responsible for her death and wanted her money. He tried to get it, and what she left their son. And now he's after my money. Indirectly, he has been responsible for the death of two women. His wife's death in the car accident and the earlier suicide. He has lied to me about everything. I just don't know what to believe about him anymore." Her voice shook on the last words. Robert Bartlett would have been stunned by what she had just said to him, except that he had heard it before, and it was the nature of a sociopath and his victim. The confusing evidence and contradiction between their calculating viciousness and their extreme attention, kindness, and seduction paralyzed their victims, who wanted to believe that the good parts were true and the bad ones only a mistake. But with more and more evidence, it became harder to believe. He could tell that Hope was at that stage. She was waking up and starting to see Finn for what he was, but, understandably, didn't want to believe it. It was hard to accept all of that about someone you loved, and who had been so loving at one time.

"I don't want you to be his next victim," Robert said in a sobering tone. She already was in many ways, but he was seriously afraid that if she crossed him in some serious way, or became useless to him, Finn might kill her, drive her to suicide, or cause an accident to happen.

"Neither do I. That's why I called you," Hope said in a heartbroken voice.

"You know, what you saw in the beginning, when he was so wonderful to you, is called 'mirroring,' when a sociopath will 'mirror' back to you everything you need and want and want them to be. And then later, much later, the truth of who they are comes out," Robert told her. "What do you think you want to do, Hope?" he asked her then gently. He felt deeply sorry for her, and understood better than most people how hard it was to face this kind of thing and take action.

"I don't know what I want to do," she admitted. "I know that sounds crazy. It was so wonderful for nine months, and suddenly all this awful stuff is happening. No one had ever been as nice to me, or as loving. I just want it to go back to the way it was in the beginning." But she was trying to raise the t.i.tanic t.i.tanic, and she was beginning to see it. She just didn't want to believe it. Not yet. She wanted Finn to prove all of it wrong. She wished she'd never gotten the report and still believed the dream. She wanted to but didn't. But she felt she had to go back and see for sure. Anyone listening to her would have thought she was insane, except Robert Bartlett. She had been lucky to find him.

"That's not going to happen, Hope," he said gently. "The man you saw in the beginning and fell in love with doesn't exist. The real one is a monster, without a heart or a conscience. I could be wrong, of course, and he could just be a very troubled guy, but I think we both know what we're seeing. That man in the beginning was an act he put on for you. That act is over. This is the third act, where the villain goes in for the kill." It was the theme of everything Finn wrote. "You can go back and take another look to be sure, no one can stop you, but you could be putting yourself at risk. Maybe great risk. If you do go back, you've got to be ready to get out fast, and run like h.e.l.l if you smell danger. You can't stick around to negotiate with him. I don't usually tell people this, but I've been there. I was married to an Irish girl, the most beautiful woman you've ever seen, and the sweetest. I believed every word she told me, and her story sounds a lot like Finn's. She had a miserable childhood, her parents were both drunks, and she wound up in foster homes where people did awful things to her. She had the face of an angel and the heart of a devil. I defended her on manslaughter charges a few years after I got out of law school. I had absolutely no doubt of her innocence then. She killed her boyfriend and claimed he tried to rape her, and there was evidence to support it. I believed her. I got her off, but today I wouldn't tell you the same thing. Eventually, she left me, took every penny I had, broke my heart, and took our kids with her. I married her right after I defended her.

"Eventually she tried to kill me. She came back during the night and stabbed me, and tried to make it look like an intruder, but I knew it wasn't. I knew it was her. And I still went back to her two more times, trying to make it work, ignoring everything I knew. I loved her, I was addicted to her, and all I wanted to do was save our marriage and keep my kids. She eventually kidnapped them to Ireland seven years ago, and by some miracle they needed someone to head up the Dublin office at the time, so I jumped at it, to be close to my kids. I couldn't force her to come back to the States. She's very clever, and thank G.o.d, my kids are okay. The youngest one just left for college in the States two months ago, and I'm going back to the New York office this spring. Nuala has married two men since me, both for money, and one of them died two years ago, from a medication he was violently allergic to, which she administered to him, and convinced the judge at the inquest that she didn't. She inherited all his money. And she's going to do it to the man she's currently married to or some other guy one of these days. She has absolutely no conscience. She belongs in prison, but I don't know if she'll ever get there. She is so profoundly disturbed that she is willing to cross any line and has a deep need to get back at the world for what was done to her. No one is safe from her.

"So I know what you're dealing with here, and I think I know how you feel. It took me years to understand that the good Nuala was only an act she put on for me, but it was so G.o.dd.a.m.n convincing that I always believed her, no matter what lies she told me or what awful things she did. The kids eventually moved in with me, which didn't bother her. People like that don't make terrific parents. Their children are either accessories to their crimes, or their victims. She doesn't even see my girls now, and I don't think she cares. She's busy spending her late husband's money, the guy she killed by giving him the wrong antibiotic out of the medicine chest. It stopped his heart cold as she knew it would, and she waited an hour to call the paramedics because she 'was so upset' and claimed she was sound asleep and didn't hear him dying. And they believed her. No one has ever cried as hard as she did at the investigation. She was inconsolable. She married her defense attorney, again, and one of these days, she'll do the same thing to him or someone else. But every man she's ever left, except the dead ones, have mourned her. And so did I.

"It took me years to get over her, give up on her, and not give a d.a.m.n anymore. Until then, I went back a hundred times for more. So, I get it. If you still need to turn the boat around, no matter what the evidence, no one can stop you. You have what you saw for nine months, and felt for him, and then you have that investigator's report and what everyone who knows him, and has experienced him, said. But if you go back, Hope, be smart. With people like that, when he turns on you, all you have time to do is run. That's the best advice I can give you. If you go back to him for another round, wear your track shoes, listen closely, trust your instincts, and if something happens that worries you or scares the s.h.i.t out of you, trust yourself and get the h.e.l.l out. Fast. Don't wait to pack a suitcase." It was the best advice he could have given her, based on his own experience, and she was stunned. It was a terrifying story. But so was Finn's.

"He's all I have now," she said sadly, "and he was so good to me for all those months. Paul was the only family member I had left, and now he's gone, and so's my daughter." She was crying as she spoke.

"That's the way these people work. They prey on the naive, the innocent, the lonely, the vulnerable, and the solitary. They can't work their voodoo in a group with people watching them. They always isolate their victims, like he has you, and they pick them well. He knew that all you had was your ex-husband, who wasn't around anymore and was very sick. So he got you over to Ireland, where you have no family, no friends, no one to look out for you. You're his ideal victim. Just be aware of it when you come back. When are you coming?" He didn't ask her if but when. He knew she would. He had done the same thing, and he could tell she wasn't ready to let go yet. She needed another dose of Finn to shock her, because the evidence of the good Finn, and the memory of it, was so strong. It was a perfect example of cognitive dissonance, two sets of evidence in direct conflict with each other, all the love they lavished on people at first, and from time to time later, and the brutal, unconscionable cruelty when they took off the mask, and then put it back on again, and confused their victims even further, and tried to convince them they were insane. Many sociopaths caused suicides as a result, when perfectly sane victims couldn't figure out what was happening to them, and got pushed over the edge. He didn't want that happening to Hope. His only goal now was to be there for her, keep her alive, and help her get out when she was ready, which he could tell she wasn't yet. He knew only too well that only someone who had been there would understand. And he had been.

Hope was deeply impressed by Robert's story, his willingness to tell it to her, his honesty, and compa.s.sion for her dilemma and love for Finn. It was so hard to a.s.similate the evidence and the extreme contradiction between how he had treated her in the beginning and all she felt for him, and what everyone else said about him, and her own concerns about him now. It was the very definition of confusion and contradiction. And no one could understand it unless they had been in a similar situation themselves, as Robert had. Her willingness to go back and look again was incomprehensible to Mark.

"Thank you for not telling me how stupid I am for going back. I think I keep hoping he'll be the way he was in the beginning."

"We all hope that in matters of the heart. And more than likely, he will be, for a night at a time, or a few hours. He just won't stay that way, because it's all an act, and a way of getting what he wants. But if you get in his way, or don't give it to him, you're going to be in big trouble, and he'll strike like lightning. Hopefully, the worst he'll do is scare the s.h.i.t out of you. Let's try to keep it at that." That was his only goal now. Hers was still the hope that Finn was what he had seemed, and would straighten up and treat her right. Robert knew there was no chance of that, but Hope had to experience it for herself. Maybe more than once. He hoped not. She was the cla.s.sic victim of a sociopath. Isolated, confused, incredulous, vulnerable, inordinately hopeful, and not yet ready to believe the evidence at hand. "Why don't you come and see me before you go back? You can stop in at my office on the way back to Russborough when you get to Dublin. I'll give you all my numbers, we can have a cup of coffee, and then you can go back to Jack the Ripper." He was teasing her and she laughed. It was not a pretty picture, and she felt a little foolish, but he was right. "I'd offer to come and see you at the house, but my guess is that that would get you in trouble. Most sociopaths are extremely jealous."

"He is. He's always accusing me of flirting with someone, even waiters in restaurants."

"That's about right. My wife was always accusing me of sleeping with my secretaries, the au pair, women I'd never even met, and eventually she started accusing me of sleeping with guys. I was constantly defending myself and trying to convince her that I wasn't. As it turned out, she was." It was projection at its best.

"I don't think Finn cheats on me," Hope said, sounding certain of it. "But he accuses me of sleeping with just about everyone in the village, including our workmen."

"Try not to get him excited about anything for the moment, if you can help it. I know that's hard. The accusations are never rational or based on fact, or rarely, unless you give him something to worry about." But she didn't sound like the type. She sounded honest, honorable, and straightforward, and she was feeling much better since their conversation, and no longer crazy. "My guess is that you'll get into it with him over the money. That's bound to be his number-one goal, and the wedding, and maybe a baby." He didn't tell her that most sociopaths were extremely s.e.xual. Nuala had been the best thing in bed that had ever hit him. That was one of the many ways they got control of their victims. In his ex-wife's case, she screwed them blind. So blind they didn't know what hit them, and then she killed them. He had narrowly escaped that fate at her hands. A good therapist and his own common sense had saved him. And even though she was still in love with Finn and her illusion of him, Hope sounded sensible to him too. The truth was very hard to swallow and believe, and the dichotomy too extreme to make sense to a sane person, so she was giving him the benefit of the doubt, which their victims often did. It wasn't stupidity on her part, just hope, naivete, faith, and love, however undeserved.

As Hope thought about it while talking to him, she decided to fly back the next day, on the night flight she liked to take, which would put her in Dublin the following morning. And she liked the idea of seeing Robert Bartlett before she went back to the house. It would ground her. She made an appointment with him for ten o'clock that morning, after she got through immigration and customs, and came in from the airport.

"That's fine. I'll be clear all morning," he a.s.sured her. And then he had another thought. "What do you want to do with that house when this is over, when that happens?" This wasn't a divorce where she owed him a settlement to end it.

"I don't know. I've thought about it, and I can't decide." She still hoped it wouldn't come to that but was well aware now that it might, and had to give it some thought. "I could keep it and keep renting it to him, but I'm not sure I'd want to. It could turn out to be a link to him I don't want. But I feel mean just throwing him out." Robert knew it was all Finn deserved, but Hope clearly wasn't there yet. And she still wished that would never happen, but Robert wanted to bring it up.

"You don't need to worry about it now. Enjoy New York, and I'll see you day after tomorrow." She thanked him again and hung up. It was six-thirty in the morning by the time she finally went to bed, feeling calmer than she had in months. At least now she had a support system in Ireland, and Robert Bartlett clearly knew the subject. It sounded as though what he'd been through with his ex-wife was far worse. She was an extreme example of the breed, but with two women dead because of him, and a lifetime of lies, Finn wasn't much better. Hope could see that. The sad thing was that in spite of all she knew about him now, she still loved him. She had believed everything that he had been to her in the beginning, and it was hard to give up that dream. She was deeply attached to him, particularly now with Paul gone. Finn really was the only person she had left in the world, which would make it that much harder to give him up. It would mean she was entirely alone for the first time in her life.

Finn called her twice that morning as she slept. She stirred and saw his number on her cell phone, turned over, and didn't answer. And when she went back to Ireland, because she would see Robert Bartlett on the way, she wasn't going to tell Finn she was coming, and she would surprise him when she got back to the house. But she wanted a few hours alone with Robert Bartlett in Dublin first.

Chapter 19.

As it turned out, it snowed the night Hope left New York, and her plane sat on the runway, delayed, for four hours, waiting for the storm to lessen. They eventually took off, but the winds were against them, and it was a long b.u.mpy flight to Dublin. There were delays getting the bags off the plane, and instead of arriving at Robert Bartlett's office at ten in the morning, she arrived at two-thirty in the afternoon, tired and disheveled, dragging her finally retrieved suitcase behind her.

"I'm so sorry!" she apologized as he came out to greet her. He was a tall, slim, distinguished-looking man with graying sandy-blond hair, green eyes, and a cleft in his chin that was more noticeable when he smiled, which he did often. He had a friendly face, and a warm demeanor. He made tea for her while she settled into one of the comfortable chairs in his office. The law firm was in a small historical building in Southeast Dublin, on Merrion Square, near Trinity College. There were lovely Georgian houses and a large park. The floors of his office were crooked, the windows were off center, and the general atmosphere was one of cozy disorder. It was a far cry from their fancy, sterile New York office. Robert liked this much better, and was almost sorry he was going back. And after seven years in Dublin he was very much at home there, and so were his children. But he wanted to be closer to his children, both of whom were in college now at Ivy League schools on the East Coast, although he said that one of them wanted to come back to Ireland after college.

He and Hope talked for hours about the vagaries of Finn, the lies he had told, and her hope that somehow, magically, things would get better. Robert knew not to argue with her, but he kept reminding her of the evidence she did have, and the unlikelihood that Finn would mend his ways now, even if he loved her. Robert knew it was a slow process giving up the dream, and all he hoped was that Finn didn't do something really terrifying to her in the meantime. He reminded her again and again to trust her instincts, and get out if she felt she should. He couldn't say that to her often enough, and wanted to impress her with it. It was essential, and she promised him that she wouldn't stay if she was uncomfortable, but she didn't think Finn would harm her physically. His style these days seemed to be more psychological torture. And she hadn't told him yet that she was coming back, and surely not that she was spending the day in Dublin with an attorney before she did.

By the time they had finished talking, it was five o'clock and Robert told her that he wasn't comfortable with the idea of her going back to Blaxton House in the evening. She had to rent a car, which would take time, and then get there, and she had already said how uncomfortable she was driving in Ireland, particularly at night. Worse than that, she might arrive when Finn was in a black mood or drinking. Winfred and Katherine would have gone back to the village for the night. He just didn't think it was smart. He suggested she stay at a hotel in Dublin that night, and go back in broad daylight the next morning. And as she thought about it, she agreed with him. She was anxious to see Finn, although nervous about it, but getting there late in the evening could mean putting her head in the lion's mouth if he'd been drinking. It just wasn't smart, and she agreed.

Robert suggested a hotel she knew, and his secretary made a reservation for her. It was the best hotel in Dublin. And since he was leaving the office, he offered to drop her off with her suitcase, which she gratefully accepted. It had been a pleasant afternoon talking to him, although the subject was difficult. What was happening in her life was so disappointing and painful. As hard as it was to justify or explain, she was still in love with Finn, the one she had known in the beginning, not the man he was now. It was hard to believe and absorb all the terrible things she'd heard about him, yet she had doubts about him herself. But when she had asked for the investigation, she hadn't expected to get the kind of information she did. Now she had to decide what to do about it. But sadly, it didn't change how attached she was to him, which only made the distressing discoveries hurt more. It seemed like a huge problem. Robert had said to her that afternoon that ultimately the situation would take care of itself. It was the kind of thing her teacher in India would have said, or her favorite monk in Tibet. And for the rest of the way to the hotel, she talked about her travels. Robert was impressed, and they had a very agreeable conversation.

The doorman took her bag when they reached the hotel, and Robert turned to her with a kind expression. He knew this was a hard time for her, and she was anxious about seeing Finn the next morning. She had no idea what to expect, or what kind of mood he'd be in. There was no way to know if she'd be meeting the good Finn or the bad Finn, the old Finn or the new Finn, and she had admitted to Robert that she was feeling very stressed about it, particularly after his many warnings about what potentially lay ahead.

"Would you like to go out for an easy dinner tonight? Pizza? The pub? There's a halfway decent Chinese place not far from here. And a really good Indian one, if you like hot food. I've got a court appearance tomorrow, and I know you want to get on the road early, so if you want to grab a bite, I could pick you up in an hour. I only live a few blocks from here." She actually liked the idea. He was a nice person, and she was feeling jangled by everything she had in her head. She didn't really want to eat alone in her room, or go out on her own in Dublin, it seemed too depressing, and it would be friendlier dining with him. He was just an ordinary decent man, but a smart one, and Mark had said he was an excellent attorney. She appreciated his advice so far, a lot of which wasn't legal, but even more useful to her, given the situation she was in.

"I'd love that," Hope said gratefully, looking tired and worn out.

"Terrific. Put on a pair of jeans, and I'll pick you up in an hour."

She checked into her room, which was small, elegant, and clean. She didn't need anything fancy, and she lay down on the bed for a few minutes, before taking a shower, putting on jeans, and brushing her hair. He was back in exactly an hour, as promised. And as she looked at Robert as they drove to the restaurant in his car, it was hard to imagine him in the clutches of the evil Nuala, or even besotted with her. He looked like an even-tempered, sensible person. He had worn jeans that night too, with a sweater and a pea coat, and he looked younger than he had in a suit. She guessed him to be about Finn's age, and close to hers. He said he was originally from California. San Francisco. And had gone to Stanford, followed by Yale Law School. She told him about her father teaching at Dartmouth, and he laughed and said he loved beating them when he played football for Stanford. He said Dartmouth had a great team. He had played amateur ice hockey too, at Yale, and still looked fit and healthy, although he claimed he wasn't. But he said he loved to go skating with his girls, both of whom were on sports teams in college. He was looking forward to seeing them for Christmas. They were all meeting in New York for the holidays, staying at the Pierre, and he was planning to start looking for an apartment, since he was moving back in March or April.

Hope had no idea where she'd be by then. Either back in New York, heartbroken, or still in Ireland, things having settled down with Finn, maybe even married. She sounded hopeful, and Robert nodded and didn't comment. He had said enough on the phone and that afternoon. Hope had all the information she needed, and he hoped that when she was ready, she'd use it. It was all he could do. There was nothing for him to do for her legally at the moment, except be available to her. She now had his office, home, and cell phone numbers written down on a piece of paper in her bag. And he told her to use them, and not be shy if she needed advice or help at any hour. That's what he was there for, and he was happy to help.

The curry was delicious and they talked about her travels again. He was fascinated by her stories, and her work, and said he had never been anywhere exotic. Just Europe and Scandinavia, mostly on business. He looked like a typical Ivy League suburban husband, with an extra dose of kindness in his eyes.

They finished dinner early and he took her back to the hotel, and wished her luck for the next day, and a good rest that night.

"Remember, you're not alone now. I'm an hour away at any time. If you get in real trouble, call me, and I can get help to you in minutes. Or call the police. Or just get out." She smiled at what he said, it was like preparing for a war, and she didn't think that Finn would ever be violent with her, or dangerous. He would be upsetting, and argue with her, or drink too much and then pa.s.s out, but it wouldn't get worse than that. She knew him well and rea.s.sured Robert. His wife had been an exceptional case.

Much to her surprise, Hope slept extremely well that night. She felt peaceful and safe, and it was rea.s.suring to know that she had a friend in Dublin. Everything Robert had said had made her feel less isolated, and she called his office before she left the hotel and left a message, thanking him for dinner. She was careful to leave the hotel by nine A.M. A.M. for the car rental place. She wanted to be heading for Russborough by nine-thirty. When she flew in, they normally got to the house by eleven, and she was planning to tell Finn that she had arrived on the morning flight to surprise him. She had sent him a loving text message the night before, and he hadn't responded. She hoped he was writing. And she had no intention of telling him that she had spent the night at a hotel in Dublin. That would make him suspicious and inevitably jealous. She looked neat and rested as she drove toward Blessington, and then Russborough, and as though perfectly timed, she arrived at Blaxton House at ten to eleven. There was no one outside, and it was a wintry December day, with a light veil of snow on the ground. for the car rental place. She wanted to be heading for Russborough by nine-thirty. When she flew in, they normally got to the house by eleven, and she was planning to tell Finn that she had arrived on the morning flight to surprise him. She had sent him a loving text message the night before, and he hadn't responded. She hoped he was writing. And she had no intention of telling him that she had spent the night at a hotel in Dublin. That would make him suspicious and inevitably jealous. She looked neat and rested as she drove toward Blessington, and then Russborough, and as though perfectly timed, she arrived at Blaxton House at ten to eleven. There was no one outside, and it was a wintry December day, with a light veil of snow on the ground.

She left her suitcase in the car, bounded up the front steps, and saw Winfred as soon as she walked into the house. He touched his brow in a gesture of respect, smiled broadly, and went out to get her bag, while she rushed up the steps to their bedroom. Suddenly, she was excited to see Finn. It was as though all the terrible things people had said had disappeared. They couldn't be true about Finn. She loved him too much for any of that to be true about him. It was all a mistake. It had to be.

She tiptoed to their room and opened the door. It was dark, he was asleep in bed, and there was an empty scotch bottle on the floor beside him, which explained why he hadn't responded to her text message the night before. He had obviously been drunk.

She slipped onto the bed next to him, looked at his handsome face for a long moment, loving him all over again, and gently kissed him. She was under his spell again the moment she saw him. He didn't stir until she kissed him once more, and then he opened an eye, saw her, and gave a start, and then he beamed at her and pulled her into his arms. He reeked of scotch, but she didn't care as he kissed her. He smelled like an open bar, which worried her for him, but she didn't say anything about it. She wondered how the writing was going, and how close he was to delivering at least one of the two ma.n.u.scripts he owed them. They were going to uphold the lawsuit if he didn't, and she didn't want that to happen to him.

"Where did you come from?" he asked with a slow, sleepy smile, stretched, and then turned over.

"I came home to see you," she said tenderly as he put his arms around her and pulled her closer, and as he did, all the good advice she'd been given was forgotten, as Robert Bartlett knew it would be. But he also knew she'd have it in her head when she needed it, at the right time.

"Why didn't you call me? I'd have come to pick you up," he said as he pulled her into bed with him, took her clothes off, and she didn't fight him.

"I wanted to surprise you," she said sweetly, and he forgot about what she was saying. He had a much better surprise for her, but it was no surprise. Their s.e.x life had been fantastic from the first, which was part of the excitement of being with him. It was irresistible, even if she knew better than to fall for his seductive charms again. He was hard to resist. And minutes later they were making wild, pa.s.sionate, insatiable love, as though the world was about to come to an end, and for a moment it always felt as though it might.

It was afternoon when they got up, bathed, dressed, and he looked at her. He was being so sweet to her again. It was hard to believe that he could ever tell a lie, hurt anyone, or make anyone unhappy, even her.

"I missed you so much," he said, and she could see that he meant it. He really did. She had found five empty scotch bottles under the bed. He had drowned his sorrows while she was gone, or his fears. He was like a child sometimes.

"I missed you too," she said gently. And then they went downstairs together and went for a walk before dark. It was snowing lightly, and looked beautiful. They were going to spend Christmas there alone. Michael was going skiing in Aspen with friends. And Hope had no one now. Only Finn.

"I'm sorry you had to go through all that with Paul. It must have been rough." He looked sympathetic and she nodded, as they held hands and walked. She tried not to think about it, or it would have panicked her that Paul was gone. And then he asked her a question that startled her in its bluntness. He wasn't usually that crude. "What's happening with the estate?"

"What do you mean?" She looked at him, shocked.

"You know ... what happens now? ... do they just give you the money, or do you have to wait until they sell stock or something?"

"That's a strange question. What difference does it make? It takes a while to probate the estate. Months, a year. I don't know. I don't care." And she didn't know why he would. They weren't dependent on Paul's money. Hope had enough, from what he had given her before. More than enough, as Finn knew only too well, since she had told him. "I just miss him," she said sadly, changing the subject. His interest in her money, and now Paul's, unnerved her and brought reality home to her again.

"I know you do," Finn said sympathetically, and put an arm around her shoulders, pulling her closer to him. "You're all alone now," he said, although he didn't need to rub it in. She was well aware of it herself, too much so. "All you have is me." She nodded and said nothing and wondered where he was going with what he was saying. "We have each other. That's all we have." She thought of his old fusion theory. He hadn't mentioned it in a while.

"You have Michael," she reminded him. And the next thing he said hit her like a punch in the solar plexus, and he was a big man and packed a powerful punch.

"And Mimi's gone," he said softly, as Hope tried to catch her breath and steady herself from the blow. It was his stock-in-trade now, putting her off balance and making her unstable, hurting her when she least expected it, in all the ways that hurt most. "That just leaves me," he repeated for emphasis. Hope didn't answer, and they walked along in the falling snow. But he had hit his mark. She felt even sadder than she had before, and then they went back to the house. He had been reminding her that she was dependent on him now, and without him she was alone. It was a shot across her bow. And she suddenly found herself thinking of Robert and his many warnings. They had agreed that he wouldn't call her, so Finn didn't get angry or upset. But if she needed Robert, she knew where to reach him. She had all his numbers in her purse.

She and Finn cooked dinner together that night, and he went upstairs to work while she got things ready, and he was wearing an odd expression when he came back downstairs to the kitchen in the bas.e.m.e.nt. They still needed to restore that. It was functional, but grim. Most of the time they used the pantry on the main floor, but not that night.

Just as they sat down at the kitchen table where the servants used to eat, Finn turned to her with a glint in his eyes, and she wondered if he'd had a drink after their walk, or maybe even before. He was drinking way too much these days. He never used to, but he did now. She wondered if the pending lawsuit was causing him to drink.

"Where were you last night?" he asked her innocently.

"On the plane. Why?" She could feel her heart race, and looked blank as she served him pasta from a large bowl.

"Are you sure?" he asked, looking her in the eye.

"Of course I am. Don't be silly. Where else would I have been? I got here this morning." She dug a fork into her pasta, and he slammed her pa.s.sport and a notepad onto the table next to her plate.

"Tell me about it. You stayed at a hotel in Dublin. I found this notepad in your purse when I was looking for something. I called them. And you were there last night. Your pa.s.sport says you arrived in Ireland yesterday. Not today." And then he produced the piece of paper with Robert's numbers. She had written down only "Robert," no last name. Finn was an excellent detective. And Hope felt like she was going to have a heart attack. It was hard to explain. She had taken the notepad off the desk at the hotel without thinking. And Finn had found it. It never occurred to her to ask what he was looking for in her purse, she was too scared. Her night in Dublin was going to be hard to explain.

She had no choice but to be honest with him. She always had been until now. It was the first time she had ever lied to him, about her arrival, or anything else. "You're right. I arrived yesterday. I wanted a night to myself in Dublin. And I met with an attorney from my New York law firm. They thought I should see a lawyer here, about taxes, residency issues, this house. I met him, stayed at the hotel, and drove here this morning. End of story. I'm sorry that I lied." She looked remorseful, and she was not going to tell him about dinner with Robert, or Finn might go into a jealous rage, and there was no way he would believe it was innocent. He never did. In spite of herself, Hope looked frightened and was shaking.

"And Robert?"

"He's the attorney."

"He gave you his home and cell numbers? You f.u.c.ked him at the hotel, didn't you, you little s.l.u.t. And who were you f.u.c.king in New York? Your agent? Or some guy you picked up at a bar? A trucker on Tenth Avenue maybe while you took his picture." He knew she went to places like that to take photographs, and he used it against her now. "Did you take pictures of his c.o.c.k?" He spat the words in her face, and Hope started to cry. He had never talked to her like that before, or been as crude. He was starting to cross boundaries he never had. Robert had warned her that he would, and she didn't believe him. "What about Robert? Was he good? Not as good as I am, I'll bet." Hope didn't comment. She just sat there at the table looking paralyzed and ashamed. He made her feel like a tramp, and she had done nothing wrong. She had seen a lawyer and had dinner, and would never have considered doing anything more. It didn't cross her mind. That wasn't who she was. But he accused her of it, with venom in his eyes and poison in his mouth.

"Nothing happened, Finn. I met with a lawyer, that's all."

"Why didn't you tell me about it?"

"Because sometimes my business is private." And even if it had been business, he would have insisted on coming with her. He never let her do anything alone. It was all about control. He even wanted to go to the doctor with her, as he had to the fertility doctor in London. He was intrusive, and wanted to be in full control of her at all times.

"How private was it?" he asked, looking at her, and this time she was sure he'd been drinking. If not, he was insane. And maybe he was that too. He looked like a crazy person as he glared at her, knocked his chair back until it fell, and paced around the kitchen, while she watched him, trying not to anger him further. She sat very still, praying that he'd back down.

"You know I wouldn't do anything like that," she said, trying to sound calmer than she felt.

"I don't know s.h.i.t about you, Hope. And you know even less about me." It was probably the most honest thing he had ever said to her about himself, but the way he said it wasn't rea.s.suring. "For all I know, you're a wh.o.r.e who blows every guy you meet whenever I'm not around." If Hope had dreamed of finding the old Finn when she got there, she had encountered the new Finn instead, an even newer one, who was worse. The real one.

"Why don't we calm down and eat dinner. Nothing happened in Dublin. I spent the night in a hotel alone. That's all." She sat straight in her chair, looking dignified and small, and before she knew what had happened, he grabbed her out of her chair, and slammed her up against the wall. She nearly flew across the room in his grip, and let out a gasp as she hit the wall with her back, and he lowered his face next to hers.

"If you ever f.u.c.k anyone, Hope, I'll kill you. Do you understand that? Is that clear to you? I won't put up with that from you. Get that through your head right now." She nodded, unable to speak, while tears choked her throat. She could hear a grinding in her ears from when he'd slammed her against the wall, and she was sure it was the sound of her heart breaking. "Answer me! Do you understand?"

"Yes," she whispered. She was sure that he was drunk. He wouldn't behave that way if he weren't. But if so, they had to do something about it. Or he did. He was under a lot of stress over the lawsuit and the books he had to write. It was obviously driving him over the edge, and now her with it.

He slammed her back into her seat then, and glared at her while she pecked at her dinner. The look in his eyes was not one she recognized. She had never seen him that way before, and it occurred to her as she moved the pasta around her plate and pretended to eat it that she was alone in the house with him. Winfred and Katherine went home at dinnertime, and she was alone with Finn every night until morning. It had never worried her before, but it did now for the first time.

There were no more outbursts during dinner. He didn't say a word to her. He took the piece of paper with Robert's numbers on it, shredded it, and then shoved the pieces into the pocket of his jeans so she couldn't find them. He left the pad and pa.s.sport on the table. And then without a word, he left the room, and left her to clean up. She sat for a long time at the table, with tears streaming down her cheeks and choking on sobs. And he had made the point earlier. She was alone in the world now. All she had was him. She had nowhere to turn, and no one to love her. With Paul gone, she felt like an orphan in a fairy tale, and the handsome prince was turning into a wild beast.

It took her an hour to calm down and clean up the kitchen. She spent most of it crying, and was afraid to go upstairs, but she knew she had to. And when she thought about it calmly, she realized that the fact that she'd spent the night in Dublin didn't look good. The piece of paper with Robert's numbers on it looked suspicious. She could see why he was upset, since she had lied to him about it when she'd arrived. She realized that she should have told him the truth about when she was coming, but if she had, she would never have been able to meet with Robert and she was glad she had. It had been helpful and good to know that she could turn to someone somewhere, if she needed to, to help her. And he was at least nearby. But she could also understand that Finn was upset that she had disappeared for a day and lied to him about her arrival. Although it had been innocent, she felt guilty about it, and in some way didn't blame him.

She dreaded going upstairs to see him, and was surprised to find when she did, that he was sitting in bed waiting for her. He looked peaceful and as though the scene in the kitchen hadn't happened. Seeing him go from one mood to the extreme opposite like that was terrifying. One moment br.i.m.m.i.n.g with rage like a dragon, the next calmly in bed, smiling at her. She wasn't sure if he was crazy or she was, and she stood looking at him for a moment, with absolutely no idea what to say.

"Come to bed, Hope," he said, as though they'd had a pleasant evening, which they certainly hadn't. It had been anything but that, and now he looked like it had never happened. Watching him lie there, all innocence, made her want to cry.

She got into bed cautiously beside him a few minutes later, after brushing her teeth and putting on her nightgown. She glanced at him as though he were a poisonous snake about to strike.

"Everything is fine," he said to her soothingly, and put an arm around her. It was almost worse than if he were still angry at her. This was just too confusing. "I was thinking," he said easily, as she lay there stiffly beside him, waiting to see what would come next. It was impossible to relax now. "I think we should get married next week. There is no reason for us to be waiting. We're not going to have a wedding anyway, with people coming from far away. And I don't want to wait any longer. We're all alone in the world, Hope, you and I. If anything ever happens to either of us, like what just happened to Paul, we should be married. No one wants to die alone."

"Paul was very sick, for a long time. And I was with him," she said in a choked voice.

"If either of us has an accident, the other would be unable to make decisions. You don't have kids or family. Michael's not here for me. We only have each other." It was a recurring theme for him tonight, to emphasize her solitude and remind her that she only had him to rely on. "I'd feel better if we were legally married. We can always have a party later, in London, New York, or Cape Cod. It's time, Hope, it's been a year. We're grown-ups. We love each other. We know what we want. There's no point waiting. And we need to get going on the baby project again," he said, smiling at her. It was as though the scene in the kitchen had never happened. An hour before, he had been threatening her and slamming her into a wall, and now he wanted to get married in a week, and get her pregnant. Listening to him, Hope felt insane. "It's been six months since you lost the last baby," he reminded her, and for once he didn't say it was her fault. It was as though he had cleared his pipes in the kitchen, and now he was his old self again. The good Finn was back with them, tucked into bed with her. But she no longer believed what she was hearing. She didn't trust it, or him. Not at all.

And she wasn't ready to marry him, by any means, and she had the strong impression this was only about money. If he was married to her, and anything happened to her in that isolated house in the Irish countryside, he would be the heir to her fortune, and to Paul's once that came to her. And with a child, she would be even more locked in. Robert had pointed that out to her the day before in his office, and it was obvious to her too. But she didn't want to get Finn mad at her again by saying she wasn't ready to get married. At least not tonight. She'd feel better talking about it in the morning, with Winfred and Katherine around, in broad daylight. Not when she was alone in the house, and he might fly into another rage like the one in the kitchen. She'd had enough excitement for one night.

"Can we talk about it tomorrow?" she said evenly. "I'm exhausted." The scene with him at dinner had made her feel like she'd been hit by a bus. For several minutes, she had been terrified of him. But he seemed totally calm now, and even loving. She felt as though he had ripped through all her gears, and she was still trembling inside and felt very tense. She tried not to let it show.

"What's to talk about?" he asked, putting an arm around her. "Let's just do it." She could tell that this was going to be the subject of their next big fight.

"We don't have to make that decision tonight, Finn," she said softly. "Let's go to sleep." It was still early, but she just couldn't deal with it anymore. She was too hurt, too upset, too disappointed, and had been too frightened to want to talk about anything with him. All she wanted to do was go to sleep, or maybe die. She knew suddenly that this wasn't going to get better, and it was going to be one fight after another. After his attack on her at dinner, she was losing hope, however nice he was now. It wasn't likely to last long.