Copyright: Its History and Its Law Part 13

{Sidenote: Extraterritorial notice}

The requirement (sec. 9) that the notice of copyright "shall be affixed to each copy published or offered for sale in the United States by authority of the copyright proprietor" makes clear what was a subject of dispute under the old law. The courts, however, generally held that extraterritorial notice of copyright, _i. e._ on foreign editions, was impracticable and unnecessary; and this view is specifically adopted in the new code. In 1905, in Harper _v._ Donohue, it was held by Judge Sanborn, in the U. S. Circuit Court, that the omission of the American copyright notice from an English edition could not vitiate copyright here, especially in view of the prohibition in the law of the importation of foreign-made copies of copyright works. In 1908, in Merriam _v._ United Dictionary Co., it was held by the U. S. Supreme Court, through Justice Holmes, that even where the omission of the notice on a foreign-made edition was with the a.s.sent of the American copyright proprietor, there was no waiver of copyright in this country.

{Sidenote: Successive editions}

In the case of successive printings or editions of a copyrighted book, the original copyright entry must appear in every reprint of the first edition; and it would seem that this entry should also appear in every new edition newly copyrighted, as well as the new notice, so long as it is desired to protect the matter contained in the old edition. Judge Clifford, in the U. S. Circuit Court, in Lawrence _v._ Dana, in 1869, ruled this to be superfluous; but his decision is contrary to the rule that a proprietor may not claim through the copyright notice a longer term than the law permits, since a later date, referring only to new matter, but apparently comprehensive of the whole contents, might be voided under this rule. It is doubtful whether on a new edition with old and new matter one copyright notice with two dates is safe, and the wiser course is to give both the earlier copyright notice and the later notice in proper sequence. In the case of new printings of works published and copyrighted prior to July 1, 1909, no new notice or application is required unless there is added material to be additionally protected and const.i.tuting to that extent a new work, in which case a new application and the deposit of two copies is necessary.

{Sidenote: False copyright notice}

Provision is specifically made against false notice of copyright by the enactment (sec. 29): "That any person who, with fraudulent intent, shall insert or impress any notice of copyright required by this Act, or words of the same purport, in or upon any uncopyrighted article, or with fraudulent intent shall remove or alter the copyright notice upon any article duly copyrighted shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars and not more than one thousand dollars. Any person who shall knowingly issue or sell any article bearing a notice of United States copyright which has not been copyrighted in this country, or who shall knowingly import any article bearing such notice or words of the same purport, which has not been copyrighted in this country, shall be liable to a fine of one hundred dollars," and the importation of any article bearing a notice of copyright when no American copyright exists is absolutely prohibited (sec. 30).

{Sidenote: Ad interim protection}

It should be noted that the copyright notice is not required on books published abroad in the English language before publication in this country, entered for _ad interim_ copyright, and therefore that within sixty days after the publication abroad of a book in the English language, such book may be protected by American registration, though containing no notice of copyright; and within this period inquiry at the Copyright Office is necessary to determine the status of the book.

{Sidenote: Subst.i.tution of name}

It is provided (sec. 46): "That when an a.s.signment of the copyright in a specified book or other work has been recorded the a.s.signee may subst.i.tute his name for that of the a.s.signor in the statutory notice of copyright prescribed by this Act." This applies only where the entire copyright has been a.s.signed and the a.s.signment duly recorded in the Copyright Office as provided by law, and does not permit a change of name in the copyright notice under any other circ.u.mstances, as partial a.s.signment. Subst.i.tution without authority of law voids copyright, as was held in Record & Guide Co. _v._ Bromley in 1910, where another trade name of the copyright claimant was subst.i.tuted for the original trade name.

{Sidenote: Registration}

The method of registration, or rather of application therefor, is not specified in the law, for the reason that under the code of 1909 deposit succeeding publication is made the act completing the securing of copyright, and registration is incidental thereto instead of the first requisite. Under the old law it was decided in the U. S. Circuit Court through Judge Colt, in Gottsberger _v._ Estes, that publication before deposit of copies voided the copyright.

{Sidenote: Rules and regulations}

The act provides (sec. 53): "That, subject to the approval of the Librarian of Congress, the Register of Copyrights shall be authorized to make rules and regulations for the registration of claims to copyright as provided by this Act," and (sec. 54) "whenever deposit has been made in the Copyright Office of a copy of any work under the provisions of this Act, he shall make entry thereof."

{Sidenote: Application}

It is provided (sec. 5): "That the application for registration shall specify to which of the [stated] cla.s.ses the work in which copyright is claimed belongs," but it is also provided "nor shall any error in cla.s.sification invalidate or impair the copyright protection." In Green _v._ Luby, in 1909, the U. S. Circuit Court protected a vaudeville sketch, though cla.s.sified as a dramatic instead of a dramatico-musical copyright, against infringement by a mimic performance.

{Sidenote: Certificate}

It is further provided (sec. 55): "That in the case of each entry the person recorded as the claimant of the copyright shall be ent.i.tled to a certificate of registration under seal of the Copyright Office, to contain his name and address, the t.i.tle of the work upon which copyright is claimed, the date of the deposit of the copies of such work, and such marks as to cla.s.s designation and entry number as shall fully identify the entry. In the case of a book the certificate shall also state the receipt of the affidavit as provided by section sixteen of this Act, the date of the completion of the printing, or the date of the publication of the book, as stated in the said affidavit. The Register of Copyrights shall prepare a printed form for the said certificate, to be filled out in each case as above provided for, which certificate, sealed with the seal of the Copyright Office, shall, upon payment of the prescribed fee, be given to any person making application for the same, and the said certificate shall be admitted in any court as _prima facie_ evidence of the facts stated therein. In addition to such certificate the Register of Copyrights shall furnish, upon request, without additional fee, a receipt for the copies of the work deposited to complete the registration."

{Sidenote: Application requirements}

The application is in general in simple form, and care should be taken in filling out the card that the s.p.a.ce at the top intended for use by the Copyright Office should be left blank. The application must be signed with the name and address of the copyright claimant, who may be the author or his representative, as where his publisher is taking out the copyright. In the case of works made for hire, the employer may make application as author. The name of the author should be given on the line provided for that purpose, even though the name of the author as claimant is also given above; but in the case of anonymous or pseudonymous works, the name of the author is not required. The t.i.tle should be given exactly as on the t.i.tle-page of the book or on the work, and the other particulars called for in the application should be exactly as indicated by the work itself. The day of publication must be exactly stated, and the application cannot be made, therefore, until _after_ publication. Provision is also made on the card for the name and address of the person to whom the certificate of registration is to be sent and of the remitter of the fee, and in the case of books, the application must be accompanied by the affidavit made either on the reverse of the application card or on the separate card also provided.

In applications, as for foreign or _ad interim_ copyright, where the nationality of the author should be stated, information as to citizenship, not race, is required. A person naturalized in the United States is defined as an American. A foreign author claiming copyright because of residence, must state that he is a "permanent resident" of the United States (C. O. Rule 29).

{Sidenote: Ill.u.s.trations}

The ill.u.s.trations of a book may be separately registered, and if by lithographic or photo-engraving process must also have affidavit of manufacture in this country.

Maps and charts are cla.s.sed with works of art, and the formalities in respect to these, as well as in respect to dramatic and musical compositions, are treated specifically in the chapters on those specific subjects.

{Sidenote: Periodicals}

In respect to periodicals, application should be made as for books, but no affidavit is required; separate registration is necessary for each number published, with notice of copyright, and can be made only after publication. It is not possible to register the t.i.tle of the periodical in advance of publication. (C. O. Rule 36.) Two deposit copies of periodicals are required; but a contribution to a periodical separately registered requires the deposit of only one copy of the periodical. The entire copy should be sent, as a mere clipping does not comply with the statute. (C. O. Rule 37.) The date of publication of a periodical is not necessarily the printed date of issue, and the actual day of publication should be stated in the application, whether for the registration of the periodical itself or a contribution to it.

{Sidenote: Application cards}

The Copyright Office has prepared blank forms in library card shape, which are furnished applicants free of charge, for the several cla.s.ses of applications mentioned in the law, the cards being in _pink_, except as hereafter stated, lettered and numbered as follows: (A1) book by citizen or resident of the United States; (A1. New ed.) new edition of book by citizen or resident of the United States; (A1 for.) book by citizen or resident of a foreign country, but manufactured in the United States; (A2) edition printed in the United States of book originally published abroad in the English language, all these being double cards including affidavit of American manufacture--supplemented by _blue_ cards providing with specific instructions, (A1) for separate affidavit of American manufacture from type set or plates made in the United States, and (A2) for lithographic or photo-engraving process within the United States; (A3) book by foreign author in foreign language; (A4) _ad interim_ copyright--book published abroad in the English language; (A5) contribution to a newspaper or periodical; (B1) periodical,--for registration of single issue; (B2) periodical,--general application and deposit, supplemented by a _white_ blank for depositing single subsequent issues; (C) lecture, sermon, or address prepared for oral delivery; (D1) published dramatic composition; (D2) dramatic composition not reproduced for sale; (D3) dramatico-musical composition; (E1) published musical composition; (E2) musical composition not reproduced for sale--these supplemented by a _blue_ card (_U_), notice of use on mechanical instruments; (F) published map; (G) work of art (painting, drawing, or sculpture), or model or design for a work of art; (H) reproduction of a work of art; (I) drawing or plastic work of a scientific or technical character; (J1) photograph published for sale; (J2) photograph not reproduced for sale; (K) print or pictorial ill.u.s.tration; (R1) renewal of copyright subsisting in any work; (R2) extension of a renewal copyright subsisting in any work. Thus an applicant for copyright on an American book should send for card (A1), on which he may enter his application and also include affidavit as to American type setting, printing, and binding; if he wishes the affidavit to be separately made he should obtain also the special _blue_ card (_A_1), or if lithographic or photo-engraving is used he should obtain also the special _blue_ card (_A_2). A dramatic applicant should send for card (D1) or card (D3), respectively, for the entry of a dramatic or dramatico-musical composition; or for (D2) if he desires to copyright without reproducing for sale. The applicant for a musical composition, as distinguished from a dramatico-musical work, should send for card (E1) or (E2) respectively. The art applicant should send for card (G) for an original work of art, or card (H) for a reproduction, or for a photograph card (J1) or card (J2) respectively.

{Sidenote: Certificate cards}

Similar certificate cards, also of library size, uniformly _white_, are provided for the several cla.s.ses of registration, correspondingly lettered and numbered, except in a few cases where one certificate form serves for more than one cla.s.s or subdivision, with the addition of a general form (Z) to cover anything unprovided for in the other certificate forms. The certificate bears on one side the uniform statement of the deposit of two copies or one copy of the article named herein, and of registration for the first or renewal term, with the name of the claimant (printed in the case of a few of the publishers making most applications), and on the other side the specification (following the wording of the application and the deposit copy) of the t.i.tle or description, date of publication, receipt of affidavit (where required), receipt of copies and entry number by cla.s.s, together with the seal of the Copyright Office.

{Sidenote: Fees}

This certificate is sent without charge other than the fees directly provided for in the law (sec. 61), viz., "for the registration of any work subject to copyright, deposited under provisions of this Act, one dollar, which sum is to include a certificate of registration under seal: _Provided_, That in the case of photographs the fee shall be fifty cents where a certificate is not demanded. For every additional certificate of registration made, fifty cents.... For recording the extension or renewal of copyright provided for in sections twenty-three and twenty-four of this Act, fifty cents." The law no longer contemplates record before publication, and it is unnecessary and undesirable to send application or money previous to sending of deposit copies. In fact, as the certificate must show date of publication, publication _cannot_ be antic.i.p.ated, and money sent in advance, for individual registrations, is only an embarra.s.sment to the Copyright Office. The Office will, however, receive advance deposits from publishers of periodicals or other publishers making frequent registrations, against which each registration will be charged. Fees should be sent by money order, or at the remitter's risk, in currency (but not in stamps). Bank drafts and certified checks are accepted in practice, though the Register of Copyrights cannot legally receive checks except at his personal risk and therefore from persons known to him as in frequent relation with the Copyright Office. Postage must be prepaid on the signed application, as there is no provision for free transmission through the mails, such as applies to deposit copies. In practice the application with remittance and the deposit copies should be simultaneously sent immediately after publication.

{Sidenote: Deposit}

The law provides that deposit copies shall be sent _promptly_ after publication, and that _two complete_ copies of the _best_ edition then published (or one copy in case of a contribution to a periodical or for identification of a work not reproduced for sale) shall be deposited; and if a work is published with notice of copyright, and copies are not promptly deposited, the copyright is voided and the proprietor becomes subject to penalty three months (or in case of outlying possessions or foreign countries six months) after formal demand by the Register of Copyrights for deposit copies. The word "promptly" is indefinite and has been vaguely construed to mean "without unnecessary delay," but this does not mean the very day of publication (C. O. Rule 22). The status of undeposited works published with copyright notice and not formally demanded by the Register of Copyrights, is also not defined by the law.

In such case the copyright has not been perfected by the completing act, and it would be impracticable to proceed against an infringer, and the proprietor might be liable to penalty for false notice of copyright. In the event of such a case arising, through carelessness or otherwise, the courts would have to decide the question by definition of the word "promptly" and an interpretation of the implication that copyright is voided, meaning that the right to obtain copyright lapses, if the process is not completed without undue delay.

{Sidenote: Fragment not depositable}

The deposit copy must be the complete work; a fragment is not a work, and a part of a work cannot be copyrighted, especially as this would nullify the manufacturing clause, as set forth in the opinion of the Attorney-General, February 9, 1910.

{Sidenote: Typewriting publication and deposit}

A work may be published and deposited in typewriting copies, as set forth in the opinion of the Attorney-General of May 2, 1910, but this will not operate to avoid the manufacturing clause when the work is published in print.

{Sidenote: Legal provisions}

The completion of the copyright by deposit of copies is covered by the provision (sec. 12): "That after copyright has been secured by publication of the work with the notice of copyright as provided in section nine of this Act, there shall be promptly deposited in the Copyright Office or in the mail addressed to the Register of Copyrights, Washington, District of Columbia, two complete copies of the best edition thereof then published, which copies, if the work be a book or periodical, shall have been produced in accordance with the manufacturing provisions specified in section fifteen of this Act; or if such work be a contribution to a periodical, for which contribution special registration is requested, one copy of the issue or issues containing such contribution; or if the work is not reproduced in copies for sale, there shall be deposited the copy, print, photograph, or other identifying reproduction provided by section eleven of this Act, such copies or copy, print, photograph, or other reproduction to be accompanied in each case by a claim of copyright. No action or proceeding shall be maintained for infringement of copyright in any work until the provisions of this Act with respect to the deposit of copies and registration of such work shall have been complied with."

{Sidenote: Voiding by failure to deposit}

In case of failure to deposit, the law of 1909 provides for penalties and finally voiding of the copyright, as follows (sec. 13): "That should the copies called for by section twelve of this Act not be promptly deposited as herein provided, the Register of Copyrights may at any time after the publication of the work, upon actual notice, require the proprietor of the copyright to deposit them, and after the said demand shall have been made, in default of the deposit copies of the work within three months from any part of the United States, except an outlying territorial possession of the United States, or within six months from any outlying territorial possession of the United States, or from any foreign country, the proprietor of the copyright shall be liable to a fine of one hundred dollars and to pay to the Library of Congress twice the amount of the retail price of the best edition of the work, and the copyright shall become void."

{Sidenote: Forfeiture by false affidavit}

In the case of a printed book or periodical or of a lithograph or photo-engraving, the copies deposited must be manufactured in America, as set forth in the manufacturing provision (sec. 15) as verified in the case of a book by affidavit (sec. 16) separately treated hereafter, and the book copyright is forfeited (sec. 17) in the event of false affidavit. Thus failure to deposit, and, in the case of books, false affidavit as to American manufacture, are the two lapses of formalities which work forfeiture of copyright.

{Sidenote: Works not reproduced}

In the case of works not reproduced for sale, copyright may be secured under the provision (sec. 11): "That copyright may also be had of the works of an author of which copies are not reproduced for sale, by the deposit, with claim of copyright, of one complete copy of such work if it be a lecture or similar production or a dramatic or musical composition; of a photographic print if the work be a photograph; of a photograph or other identifying reproduction thereof if it be a work of art or a plastic work or drawing. But the privilege of registration of copyright secured hereunder shall not exempt the copyright proprietor from the deposit copies under sections twelve and thirteen of this Act where the work is later reproduced in copies for sale." The entire work should in each case be deposited (C. O. Rule 18) and not a mere outline, epitome or scenario; and the copy should be in convenient form, clean and legible, with the leaves securely fastened together, and should bear the t.i.tle of the work exactly as given in the application.

{Sidenote: Second registration}

It should be noted that in this cla.s.s of copyright, which is a common law copyright fortified by statutory protection, an ideal example of copyright law, double registration is required in case the unpublished copyrighted work is published, requiring one application fee and deposit of one identifying copy for the unpublished work and a second application fee and deposit of two copies promptly after publication.

{Sidenote: Free transportation in mail}

It should be noted that the deposit copies may be deposited either in the Copyright Office or "in the mail addressed to the register of copyrights," and it is provided (sec. 14): "That the postmaster to whom are delivered the articles deposited as provided in sections eleven and twelve of this Act shall, if requested, give a receipt therefor and shall mail them to their destination without cost to the copyright claimant." Franking labels are not required and are no longer issued by the Copyright Office. Deposit copies, and all mail matter, should be addressed to the "Register of Copyrights, Library of Congress, Washington, D. C.," and not to any person by name.